MJF # 1 voter here. Firstly- your opinion is valid and I know choosing a 30 year old wrestler who is still working is controversial and a choice I went back and forth on but one I stand by.
MJF has wrestled 550 matches. This is more matches than other GWE top 100 guys. Almost all of these matches are on tape so he is also much easier to watch a ton of than older wrestlers we all love. The guy wrestled 140 matches in 2018, he's got a good amount of in ring work.
I also think the character work which he excels at enhances his in ring. He promotes an overly cocky asshole covering underlying feelings of low self worth and a desire for human connection- all of that plays out in the way he fights in a way that, to me, presents a very strong package. I get your criticisms on his matches, it's a criticism of a lot of modern wrestling. I love it but art is subjective. MJF in Arena Mexico against Mistico, CM Punk Matches, vs. Wardlow on PPV, Texas Death against Hanger and yes even the iron man match, to me, slap.
