As a longtime lurker who reveres this board and the posters who make it so enriching, I really didn't intend to break my multiyear silence only to immediately start lobbing incendiary "takes," but...
Here's Charlotte's problem: she has all the physical gifts in the world, but anytime the real life physics of a pro wrestling match result in a different outcome from what she's picturing in her head, her inability to adapt on the fly sends everything towards weirdness in a hurry. Honestly, it seems like the problem is that she's so vain that the idea that she needs to meet her opponent halfway strikes her as preposterous - so preposterous that sometimes she feels the need to teach her opponent a lesson. It's one thing when the opponent in question is Nia Jax, but it's quite another when she's endangering Kairi Sane's life and career. At this rate, Charlotte's on track to have incidents like this with every woman on the roster, and as Nick Khan culls that roster further and further, familiarity will only breed greater contempt. I've wondered whether erstwhile boyfriend Andrade suffers from the exact same problem, but I won't venture to guess what his deal is. To some extent they remind me of Paige and ADR, but I really don't think drugs are the problem here; it's just pure ego and immaturity.
What Charlotte reminds me of most is a selfish actor whose utter lack of empathy for her fellow cast members makes every scene she's in feel leaden and self-indulgent. I don't know if there are any "It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia" fans on this board, but I thought the most recent episode, "The Gang Replaces Dee With a Monkey," spoke to Charlotte's issues well. Failed actress Dee realizes that her acting coach was ripping her off with fees when he knew she was hopeless, so she decides to start her own acting school to get in on the grift herself. Her advice to her students reveals why she never got callbacks from auditions: it's along the lines of "the other actors are your competition, so don't react to anything they say, and recite your own lines as loudly and deliberately as possible so that everyone is forced to pay attention to you." Does that not sound a bit like latter day Charlotte's approach to wrestling? She's turned into Michaels in '97/'98 except worse. At least a Soma-popping shithead is too passive to actually hurt anyone; Charlotte's purely high on her own self-regard, which makes her considerably more dangerous.
Well, there's that. So again, hello, everyone - I promise I don't intend to brandish the flamethrower like this all the time. I look forward to more upbeat conversations with you all in the future!