Watched a bunch of her work last year, 50+ matches from her early 90s AJW work to the peak ARSION stuff and her post-prime in the 2000s. The AJW work obviously doesn't hold a candle to her later career work, but she's consistently good and has a fair amount of gems to her name during this period; I especially like the 6/5/91 tag with Hokuto against Bull and Kyoko Inoue, and 1996 Japan Grand Prix match against Chaparita ASARI. She shows herself to be a real sympathetic worker, and a standout bumper to boot, but I would say it's more of a complimentary period than a true case-builder for this list.
The ARSION work, on the other hand, is absolutely unreal, and the bulk of her case. Just mind-meltingly great stuff with everyone from Rie Tamada to Ayako Hamada to Reggie Bennett to AKINO to Aja Kong. Her Queen of Arsion title matches against Hiromi Yagi and Mikiko Futagami in February and April of 1999 respectively are legit classics in my eyes, incredible in construction and execution. The speed and precision with which she moves on the mat made my jaw drop at various points over the course of watching her work, and cemented her as someone I felt compelled to vote for.
Her later period work is also quite underrated in my view, too; she's often talked up as a peak candidate from 1998-2000––for good reason––but the Megumi Fujii match in 2003, the AtoZ tournament matches against both Hotta and Momoe Nakanishi on the same night, the 2004 Carlos Amano match, and the 2006 NEO title match against Yoshiko Tamura prove to me that she was still great well beyond that peak and her later years probably haven't received enough critical examination. Hell, her 2017 retirement match against Leon is still really solid and impressive, a respectable final match for a great that wrestled for nearly three decades.
Mariko Yoshida's a lock to make my list. At her best in ARSION, her style makes even a style as celebrated as 90's AJW's seem stale and bland in comparison. One of the most compelling figures in Joshi history, and maybe second only to Shinjiro Otani in terms of convincing me that they actually give a shit about winning and losing a match.
RECOMMENDED MATCHES:
w/ Akira Hokuto vs. Bull Nakano & Kyoko Inoue (AJW 6/5/91)
vs. KAORU (AJW 8/28/94)
vs. Chaparita ASARI (AJW 8/4/96)
vs. Reggie Bennett (ARSION 5/5/98)
vs. Mika Akino (ARSION 1/17/99)
vs. Hiromi Yagi (ARSION 2/18/99)
vs. Mikiko Futagami (ARSION 4/14/99)
vs. Aja Kong (ARSION 9/17/00)
vs. Megumi Fujii (ARSION 5/24/03)
vs. Yumiko Hotta (AtoZ 11/9/03)
vs. Carlos Amano (GAEA 4/30/04)
vs. Yoshiko Tamura (NEO 11/3/06)