-
Posts
753 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Blogs
Everything posted by Ma Stump Puller
-
Steve Williams was #93 on my ballot. I really think he gets overlooked as an overall act in favour of the Hansens and Funks even if he was heavily overpushed and didn't quite "get it" for a couple of years you have his incredible 90's AJPW run where he was not only a solid main event act with nigh-unbeatable physicality and intensity but was also quite the solid TV-style worker as well around that time, namely because he could carry that intensity into those lower-card tag matches while not compromising the quality. There are also his stints in WCW and NJPW as well but primarily his work there really cemented it for me.
-
Tadao Yasuda was I believe #98 on my ballot, and primarily for the reasoning provided above; he's a excellent wrestler when it comes to character dynamics and making the best out of whatever was in front of him, which for a 35-something guy who started wrestling to get into more debt I imagine was more vital than you might realise. From scrubby-loser having to be desperately saved by Hashimoto over and over again to main-event Inoki cult leader the man really did it all and did it much better than I think a lot of people at the time and at recent would grant him.
-
I eventually decided to slot Osamu Kido at #96. While one could very easily overlook him, I think any serious Puro watcher would inevitably have to slot him somewhere on their list either for his solid contributions in the UWF/NJPW tags or I would say equally impressive showings in UWF itself. Kido gets the occasional shine slot like in his 1994 G1 run or numerous fantastic matches against Fujiwara, and his longevity alongside that (being in decent to good matches from the 1980's to all the way to 2010) is extremely commendable.
-
Wilkins was #99 on my list. He's a great example of someone who perhaps didn't have the match material to be a top 100 in terms of fancy epics but played his role as "grimy American bully" to perfection with whoever he was slotted with, and those inevitable matches where he meets someone even worse than he is (Fujiwara, Shamrock) and gets the shit kicked out of him is great. He's a small fish that picks on even smaller and almost always finds comeuppance when he eventually gets too close to the actual big fish. Wrestling needs more people capable of that level of self-awareness rather than them all thinking they can be The Guy all at once.
-
Was on ballot: Mitsuharu Misawa Mayumi Ozaki Mariko Yoshida Meiko Satomura Masa Fuchi Masakatsu Funaki Masanobu Kurisu Megumi Fujii
-
Kashin was #100 on my GWE list (and I will be probably the only one with that opinion) he does have obvious low points but when I dug through around about 150+ matches of his all off the cuff I really enjoyed what he brought to the table, and seeing some of his more obscure stuff like the match with Young Lion Shibata or the Atlantis singles made me kinda realise "oh wait this guy IS cool my bad" which I always appreciate happening.
-
Seconded, Arai was #73 on my GME list and it was mainly because of his ridiculous attention to detail and ability to be watchable regardless of what he's doing or what opponent is in front of him. Few can pull that off reliably but with Arai it feels almost natural. Would also heavily recommend his Ironman match with Mikiya Sasaki from KOBE: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Pxt0Sy49zQ They go 60 and about half of it is in a headscissors of all things, but I legitmately watched the entire thing in one go just because it was that engrossing.
-
Carlos Amano was #40 on my list, a combination of being an extremely good hand from '97 to her retirement in the mid 2010's alongside having a wide variety of solid matches with pretty much every other relevant talent around those points made her a no-brainer for me. As someone who biases consistency over a lot of other things she's the ideal candidate and she's essentially the jack of all trades with her matches being evenly spread between wacky high-energy stiff striking affairs or slower and more methodical grappling antics. The common trait in all of them is that she's a workhorse, typically doing the blunt of the bumping/selling on her own (especially against or with older talent who can't physically do it as readily as she can) alongside being very generous with how she does so; even with rookies, she’ll always give them a couple of good spots where she’ll bump big and give them the limelight even when she really has no obligation to do so. She carries the banner of being the resident great match giver in both GAEA AND JWP, sharing obligations as someone who can go out with anyone and give them a good match and push to greatness under the right conditions. Near the end she is getting a consistent spotlight at GAEA and it’s not hard to see why given the sheer amount of substantively awesome performances she had there. I wouldn't be kidding if I thought she felt like a Bret-lite figure in that her style was highly complimentary with others to the point of carrying at points depending on the person. I think the narrative of Carlos Amano works in her favor as well; she was always the least physically capable of the original JWP Four and took the longest to get great (both as a work and shoot lmao) but she was able to rely on being this timid rookie to her advantage either in a spirited early feud with her series with Bolshoi or as Ozaki’s bumbling sidekick where she more or less took a beating but was always driven to impress and focus on her positives despite still being fairly unremarkable in the fancy spot department. In tags generally she does very well in them in whatever role given, even giving a pretty out of prime Dynamite Kansai some of her I would say last truly solid affairs as this fun little/big sis dynamic where she'd do the fast portions and build to Dyna wrecking shop with her couple of spots and kicks. It's a very strong example of her being able to take any role provided and make the best out of it even if it's at somewhat her expense as a worker. Ultimately it's the fact that she feels like a Battlarts wrestler lost in time that is endearing to me, she's able to go at the usual fast-pace you would expect from the time while making it totally her own distinct style with the furry of headbutt variations or flashy submissions. That ultimately is just cool to watch for me, so seeing someone do all that while actually also being a very good wrestler is all the more the impressive.
-
I had these people on my ballot: #2 Kenta Kobashi #8 Kiyoshi Tamura #27 Keiji Mutoh #30 Keita Yano #32 Kurt Angle #39 Kaori Yoneyama #45 Kazunari Murakami #47 Kazuyuki Fujita #73 Kenichiro Arai #78 Kana/Asuka #82 Kenoh #100 Kendo Kashin
-
Kobashi was actually a pretty good grappler when he was inclined (one of his VERY early matches had a bunch of submission-throwing by him) his Johnny Smith match from 2000 also comes to mind, naturally we have all of Kawada's attempts to grapple with his shoot-style flirtations, but yeah out of the five Akiyama was the most talented when it came to conventional matworking yeah. The Hase match alone kinda defines that point.
-
This is an exhibition but I'd argue it's a lot closer to a clear worked-shoot than actually shooting, especially with the very shtick spots like Minoru doing heel antics with fakeout handshakes and turnbuckle bashing that, needless to say, is not commonplace in actual MMA. That makes me think alone that this could be considered a return to pro-wres for the man, even if it wasn't 100% overt yet like it was in 2003. We've also had legit MMA guys show up for worked shoots before numerous times, so something like this where 3 of the 4 people wrestling here did or would do pro-wres matches makes me confident this is at least leaning in that direction.
-
Nagata was #51 on my submitted list, mostly down to his longevity and wide streak of strong showings. The man is not without his faults and I think he can at times fall to predictable formulas but you've got at this point about 2 decades of great work on his end, so not a shocker that he ends up there.
-
Rookies clearly better than Senka Akatsuki
Ma Stump Puller replied to Jetlag's topic in Greatest Wrestler Ever
Akiyama's first year (he debuted in 1992, but he was only around for the last 3 months so we can't really count that as a "year") had him in prominent singles against Steve Williams, Kawada, DiBiase, Kobashi x2, then a bunch of tags. In all of them he's pretty solid and I think despite not being near the quality he would be he holds his own there. I'd say he did better than Senka though it's not as far apart as you may imagine. I put her relatively high on my VP100 list for this year and she ended up 85th overall, which for someone who just debuted is fairly insane. Tamura only wrestled a couple of times in his first year but he was already pretty fucking good, maybe over Senka in terms of quality. Hashimoto we have very little of for his first two years but he was pretty much already great and the matches we do have show him way above his class as a finished product. -
His match vs Hiroshi Hase in 1995 is a lot of fun for a relatively short match
-
100% Lock: Hiroshi Tanahashi Hiroshi Hase Maybe? HARASHIMA Harley Saito
-
Can be enjoyable (the DDT tag with Ishii is astonishingly good) and I really liked him in Battlarts but there are so many awful matches he's been apart of that I can not in good faith endorse him for something like this.
-
Potential #1 Genichiro Tenryu Definitely has a spot GENTARO Giant Baba Gran Hamada Maybe? Gunther Greg Valentine Gran Naniwa
-
Has a spot: Daisuke Ikeda Devil Masami Dick Togo Dynamite Kansai Mostly There: Dump Matsumoto Dragon Kid Maybe?: Daisuke Sekimoto Darby Allin
-
100% lock: Command Bolshoi Chigusa Nagayo Carlos Amano Almost There: Carl Greco Chihiro Hashimoto Christian Curt Hennig Maybe: Cesaro CM Punk Christopher Daniels
-
Will almost conclusively have a spot on top 100: Aja Kong AJ Styles Akira Maeda Antonio Inoki Akira Hokuto Akira Taue Has a chance of showing up: Abdullah The Butcher Atsushi Onita Alexander Otsuka Arisa Nakajima
-
As someone who ran the Yuiga propaganda train for quite a while I am unfortunately remiss to say that she will not be on my top 100. She's terrific at what she does though and is probably the GOAT at intergender matches. I could definitely see her having a slot for some people.
-
I think people really overlook his pre-comedy stuff, Yano wasn't a solid wrestler but he was better than most at being a dangerous spoiler-heel who could chain enough bullshit together to catch anyone unawares, and his more bloody showings involving his work with the WEW belt are pretty fucking cool. In another world the guy would've been scrapping with Carlos Colon in some dingy stadium. Can't see a world where he gets top 100 though
-
I like Taichi more than most, I enjoyed him when he was a hapless rookie seconding Kawada in places like HUSTLE or AJPW, I was one of the few who actually liked his Jr heavyweight stint where he just stooged and stalled for most of his matches, etc etc. I'm somewhat mixed on his material today since it seems like he's relented to becoming a NJPWism upper main event guy who needs to have 30+ minute affairs with endless false finishes and forearms while also occasionally doing something Kawada did for the sake of it. I enjoy when he's pushed outside his comfort zone like his KOPW series with Shingo, but those aren't often enough these days so his material is (mostly) just acceptable tag matches with a good match every couple of months. When he's allowed to do a bit more I think he's tolerable than most at the style however.
-
Yeah the JWP fancam files give Ran some pretty stellar showings; she was a far greater natural when it came to working than some of her contemporaries, even if she didn't have the same success they had overall. Had some of the most awesome elbow shots since at least Misawa and from my viewing always came across as a super worker that just never got the spotlight deserved of them. Shout out to her never having a bad match with Carlos Amano, though with their joint consistency I imagine that would be next to impossible. Maybe has a slot in the upper regions.