I've read a lot of criticism for this match and each time I watch it I expect to be horribly disappointed, yet each time I always end up amazed at what these guys did. I'll admit that I first watched this around 2010ish when all that stuff about concussions was coming out and I got a massively perverse enjoyment just from seeing the crazy shit these guys were doing to each other, but I still contend that there's a beautiful story under all that and I discover a little more of it every time I see it. This time, I was really struck by the ways that Kawada was able to project this incredible desire to win while still finding ways to get the crowd into Misawa's comeback. I love that moment early on when Misawa shows a slight expression of pain after elbowing Kawada and Kawada viciously goes after it immediately thereafter like a shark who sees blood. The way that Misawa then makes a comeback using that same elbow works great as a "fuck you" spot, but it doesn't feel like a waste of time when Kawada briefly goes back to it to cut off Misawa.
The transition towards the second half comes when Misawa sells his neck after a strike exchange as if it aggravated some old injury from the Kobashi matches, and again Kawada goes after it with all he can. The spot with 3 consecutive backdrop drivers is absolutely insane and I have no idea how people can criticize them for selling too much when they're doing shit like that to each other. I can kind of see that spawning the claims of this being the point the point where King's Road had nowhere else to go and became a more a spot-oriented style, but I think the resulting "Thrilla in Manilla" vibe, where it feels like it's two old rivals pushing each other within an inch of death, only adds to the match. I'd also say that if you compare the usage of those moves to even something like their 7/95 match, this one was actually farther from the myth of the style degenerating into spotfests built around head drops.
Also, I think it's pretty clear the triangle choke Kawada did later was not meant as a "submission attempt on the arm he hadn't worked" what with the referee checking if Misawa was still conscious and the camera being focused on his facials. The crowd did seem caught off-guard but they definitely didn't shit on it when they soon started chanting Misawa's name and were stomping their feet when he reached the ropes. If you think about it, it's actually a pretty brilliant spot both from the working perspective of giving the audience an opportunity to appreciate Misawa's tenacity and from the kayfabe perspective of Kawada just trying whatever he can to keep Misawa down when he couldn't even get him up for a powerbomb after the aforementioned 3 backdrop drivers and a stretch plum.
I also don't think the "delayed selling" should be counted against the match purely for its presence. It worked excellently to get across how deep both guys were digging and to get across their history where they both knew a single string of big moves could end the match. I love how they play up the finish to their 92 and 93 TC matches when Misawa starts pulling out the tiger suplexes and Kawada is just desperate to not stay down because he knows the doom that would spell for him. My favorite moment of the match is when Misawa hits a tiger suplex and Kawada immediately pops up, tries to support himself with the ropes, but still slowly slumps down like a tree that's been chopped down. His desire to win continued to burn but his body couldn't keep up. Right there is the central theme of the match, as anyone who saw their prior matches knows that Kawada didn't seem able to keep up with Misawa's classical perseverance in a long match, and this was him trying to overcome it with his sheer will to win.
The only criticism in here I can agree with somewhat is the referee botching the finish, but even that, knowing what we do now about taking shots after getting concussed, just adds to the sense of of primal brutality that they had created throughout the match. That visual of a groggy Kawada being hoisted up for a sloppy german after he had already been KO'd by Misawa's elbows almost transcends merely being apart of the match and becomes its own philosophical statement. It is like an exclamation point to Kawada and Misawa having pushed the concept of pro wrestling pushed to its limit. When I watch matches like this there is a slight sense of guilt knowing the ill effects that this style has on the body, but when I see these guys being forced into that finish by a veteran referee in front of hardcore fans who had been screaming madly from the opening bell, I am overcome with a calm resignation in understanding that it simply is what it is.
Edit: Also just remembered this quote from Misawa's Japanese Wikipedia page. Though it would be worth putting here, especially with someone implying before that this match's rep is just Meltzer craziness
"三沢ãŒå·ç”°ã¨å¯¾æˆ¦ã—ãŸ1997å¹´6月6æ—¥ã®ä¸‰å† 統一ヘビー級王座ã®ã‚¿ã‚¤ãƒˆãƒ«ãƒžãƒƒãƒã¯ã€é¦¬å ´ãŒã€Œã‚ã¾ã‚Šã«ã‚‚ã™ã”ã„ã€ã¨æ¶™ã—ãŸã»ã©æ¿€ã—ã„試åˆã¨ã—ã¦çŸ¥ã‚‰ã‚Œã‚‹," which Google Translate says the match is known for being so violent it had Baba crying and saying how great it was.