Nominations closed. Voting 2026-04-05 to 2026-05-05

[Grimmas]

Everyone get hyped!

Get your friends to join here or on discord!

Share the voting form when it's created! 

Let's have fun!

[bustedquad]

I’m pumped. Let’s go. 

[Boss Rock]

The 2016 vote is what introduced me to this site. Can't wait to participate in this year's.

[Tetsujin]

So excited for this. Thanks to everyone doing the work.

[Norm]

On 3/10/2026 at 9:06 PM, Boss Rock said:

The 2016 vote is what introduced me to this site. Can't wait to participate in this year's.

Same here. The marathon podcasts from Dylan and Kris specifically (as well as others) substantially shaped the way I’ve viewed wrestling the past decade. Hope we get more of those for this project. 

[DMJ]

I'm super psyched and deep in the weeds on finalizing my list. I'm glad I've still got time for more research, though I do think I've got it down to 110-120 wrestlers.

While he wouldn't make my list this year I am thinking Brody King is quietly making a case for 2036. By my own requirements - I have to have reviewed a minimum of 20 matches - he wouldn't quite get there (I've reviewed 15 and I'm not going to go out of my way to watch more of him as he's not a nominee), but as I've gone back and watched the old AEW PPVs on Max, it's become abundantly clear that he is quite often the best part of the multi-mans he's in and is working circles around his House of Black teammates (and I say this as someone who isn't a Buddy Murphy or Malakai Black hater). He had an excellent 2025/2026 with Brodido and now as a singles.

I just watched the 8-man from World's End and him getting in Matt Menard's face and essentially daring him to get involved is such good work. I think Menard might've actually had a tear in his eye from the emasculation he suffered in that moment. 

Also, extra points for the work on I Think You Should Leave.