Last nights Dave & Bryan show was fascinating...
How can you say people don't pay money to see Bryan when an entire sold out crowd at their number 2 PPV of the year PAID to see him win and wouldn't accept anything else?
Last month at MSG the advertising for the next house show had Bryan on it. Tickets went on sale during intermission. Last week they took him off MSG and put him on the Salt Lake City show with Orton. So if MSG does a big house, who gets the credit? This stuff happens all the time. People rarely even know who they are going to see at house shows because the talent scheduled changes every week.
The Jeff Hardy thing is a good argument but it's 6 years later. Money in the Bank with Punk, Rock's return at Survivor Series both bombed. The shows are going to do the same number give or take a small bump no matter what because the price is outrageous and the shows aren't good enough to justify it. Also, Hardy wasn't put down as a loser anywhere close to Bryan has been. The one thing they did to Hardy was when he beat HHH in the #1 contender's match it was a fluke and HHH got up and laughed at him. But it ended there. The music video they did for Hardy the Monday before the Rumble was one of the best they've ever done.
Bryan bringing up Orton was the perfect answer to every point Dave made. Orton isn't responsible for moving anything in terms of ratings, buys or merchandise that anyone can ever recall. But he is a chosen one, like the last 3 in the Rumble last night (Batista, Sheamus, Reigns) and the crowd threw up on them.
I've said this a hundred times this entire thing would have been avoided if they gave Bryan the belt for 2 months after SummerSlam. Orton could have won in October and it wouldn't mess up their plans. But they were set on trolling the internet for heel heat. Stephanie who is a HEEL doing the stupid chant for Batista on Monday with the big grin on her face just to troll people and then they are going to act like they didn't expect Batista to be booed out of the building last night.
And what difference does it make if Batista is in the title match at Mania or a big attraction match? He'd do the same ratings either way. Sell the same merchandise. The problem is he's a mark for himself and they had to promise him another title run to come back.