It had 30% less buys than the previous All Out, in 2021. They absolutely should take that number into consideration here, IMO.
The timing there sucked. Like, I loved what they did with the first Punk/Mox match, with it essentially being a squash, but after that they had like 3 months of story condensed into two weeks. If they kept the same angle for the first match, but did it on All Out, I am sure the numbers could be better. They did a very WCW thing of just giving big fucking matches away on TV and that bit them in the ass.