Matt D

I'm pretty sure an Owens/Rollins chinlock is the worst single in-match thing WWE could possibly produce in 2018.

I know things look good for SD, but let's all remember that we'll be getting a 10 minute Paige promo segment every week.

Mickie has the best Eclipse bump.

Part of the problem is that they didnt give us anything else up and down the card.

Wait, what ? I think this is what he is referring to. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.thesun.co.uk/sport/5092137/wwe-divas-sasha-banks-alexa-bliss/amp/ Oh wait, that was UAE. My bad there.

That makes me wonder if there was some sort of pushback to the Alexa vs Sasha match and the chants within?

Yeah but it's fine because Jose IS the biggest geek. Honestly, the real solution would have been just to do it on the pre-show or to have to not set up the match in the first place or to have Braun as part of the main and have him help beat the crap out of Roman too. It's not like this was some sort of "best possible scenario." They're the ones who got themselves in this situation in the first place.

No Way Jose was right there and probably would have fit what they were going for just as well and given him a more meaningful debut.

The podcast was certainly interesting, and I think the match is terrific. But if a podcast 20+ years later is necessary to appreciate it than they didn't do their job that night. I think there's a difference between appreciating the whole match and grapplingwith one potentially frustrating element.

Eternal youth? Not sure if you're trying to suggest that I'm "old" and out of touch. I'm really, really, really fucking sick of WWE car crash matches. *Shrug* With that said, this was a very good one. Not five-star good, though - IMO. I thought Meltz was very selective about what he gave five stars to, which makes this all the more shocking - especially with the legit five-star Gargano vs. Ciampa match on the same show (which he also rated five stars). 'Course, I'm not one to put much stock in his ratings to begin with - I'm just surprised. It seemed less petulant and more even-handed and even potentially positive than me saying that what you were lacking was "Arrested Development."

Eternal youth?

I'm now much more interested in figuring out who the best in-ring wrestler in the WWF in 1993 was than any direct comparisons. (I doubt Michaels would be in my top 5, from either an input or output perspective. I'd probably have Borne, Bret, Yoko, Kid over him easily. Maybe Hennig too).

I'm certainly not saying someone can't have an opinion the match without any other supplementary material, but anyone who cares enough to have an opinion that's lasted 20 years really ought to listen to the recent podcast where they talk about the match, including that very specific issue and their own reluctance when it was told to them that it was happening.

Roode is a really good house show worker. He's just a lot less of a TV/PPV worker.

Headcheese, I'll take laz' match (assuming you didn't pick something for him specifically) and give you this: One of the best, funniest midget matches we have on tape. Astroboy, happy to watch that. Here's yours. One of the best Super Astro matches we have on tape: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1oxrDvBYenI Solar, Ultraman y Super Astro vs. Sergio El Hermoso, Bello Greco y Rudy Reyna

Do you think that also current wrestlers think in this way? I know current wrestlers love Randy Orton because he's apparently very easy to work with (though occasionally hard to get to take a risk). The whole "Working with him is like a night off" mentality. That's obviously a metric that we as fans would almost never really rate someone on. Likewise, Christian and the fact he never got blown up no matter what you wanted to do.

Guys like Angle and Brock are so beloved by old-timers because wrestlers are marks. They give everyone who ever wrestled more of a sense of faux legitimacy. Bryan on the other hand generally looks like a guy off the street and hates to party.

I think I took you off for a week as requested and then tossed you back on (but work and home have been busy here too so I might have slipped). Anyway, I'm happy to double with HeadCheese this week. I'll have a match for him and Astroboy today.

Salvator Mundi?

The Pat O’Connor match is the best and the worst of Murdoch rolled into one.

The NXT taping sheet from last week that leaked out had Michaels and Taylor producing the Gargano match. I am going to infer that Michaels had a hand in this, as I first thought, and reiterate how I have always said that Michaels would be a better director than an actor because he lacked emotional subtlety and range. He had ideas in his late career that transcended most wrestling matches in a way that leaned towards the WWE cinematic ideal, but lacked the ability to execute them.

If you set up an expectation in your fan base, it is your fault if people are disappointed.

I always assume he just replaced Ty as the player-coach.