Rate and Compare

[Boon]

Thought it would be fun to see comparison between what actually happen vs what we do. So here goes...

 

8th August - Real

 

8/8/83 Birmingham, AL @ Boutwell Auditorium

Jimmy Golden & Robert Fuller vs. Bob Armstrong & The Flame in a loser leaves town match
Midnight Express vs. Ken Lucas & Eddie Hogan
Mr. Olympia vs. . Ricky Harris
Chic Donovan vs. Ricky Gibson

 

8th August - Fantasy

 

 

1. The Nightmares (Danny Davis & Ken Wayne) defeat The Latin Lovers (Javier Cruz & Vinnie Valentino)

2. Tom Pritchard defeats Josh Stroud

3. Bobby Eaton defeats Art Crews.

4. Southeastern Tag Team Champions The Assassins with Paul Jones defeated Ricky Gibson & Tim Horner.

5. Jimmy Golden & Robert Fuller defeat Larry Hamilton & Johnny Rich.

6. "Dirty" Dutch Mantell defeated Southeastern Heavyweight Champion "Bullet" Bob Armstrong.

[JHawk]

I'd much rather see your show but Donovan vs. Gibson on the real show sounds awesome

[goc]

I have to pick the real show but only for the main event because heel Bob Armstrong is perhaps the greatest thing ever.

[Flyin' Brian]

That's a tough one for me but I'm going to go with your show by a hair.

[Grimmas]

My show for late July at Maple Leaf Gardens:

 

1. Stephen Petipas pinned Barry Darsow @ 7:33

2. Cuban Assassin & Chicky Starr def. Angelo Rivera & Tony Garea when Starr pinned Rivera @ 10:55

3. Buddy Roberts pinned Ben Bassarab @ 12:21

4. Terry Gordy pinned Leo Burke @ 18:03

5. Mr. Saito, Masked Samurai & Jesse Ventura def. Bret Hart, Wahoo McDaniel & Tiger Conway Jr. when Saito pinned Hart @ 13:21

6. WWF Intercontinental Champion Ricky Steamboat pinned Ron Starr @ 15:54

7. Rocky Johnson pinned Michael Hayes @ 11:32

8. NWA World Midget's Champion Little Tokyo pinned Tiger Jackson @ 9:00

9. Rick Martel pinned Ric Flair @ 37:32

In real life:

1 Bob Marcus defeated Masanobu Fuchi

2 Jacques Goulet and Kelly Kiniski defeated Vinnie Valentino and Nick DeCarlo

3 One Man Gang defeated Mike Davis

4 Dory Funk Jr. defeated Mike Rotundo (23:04 minutes)

5 Rufus R. Jones defeated Jake Roberts

6 Greg Valentine defeated Cy Jernigan (9:16 minutes)

7 Jack Brisco and Jerry Brisco defeated Ricky Steamboat and Jay Youngblood by disqualification (18:22 minutes)

8 Steel Cage Match

Jimmy Valiant and Bob Orton Jr. defeated The Great Kabuki and Gary Hart

9 NWA Canadian Heavyweight Title (Toronto-Version) Match

Sgt. Slaughter defeated Angelo Mosca © (22:18 minutes) - TITLE CHANGE!!!

10 NWA World Heavyweight Title Match

Harley Race © defeated Ric Flair by disqualification (16:42 minutes)

[Flyin' Brian]

  On 8/9/2015 at 10:56 PM, Grimmas said:

 

My show for late July at Maple Leaf Gardens:

 

1. Stephen Petipas pinned Barry Darsow @ 7:33

2. Cuban Assassin & Chicky Starr def. Angelo Rivera & Tony Garea when Starr pinned Rivera @ 10:55

3. Buddy Roberts pinned Ben Bassarab @ 12:21

4. Terry Gordy pinned Leo Burke @ 18:03

5. Mr. Saito, Masked Samurai & Jesse Ventura def. Bret Hart, Wahoo McDaniel & Tiger Conway Jr. when Saito pinned Hart @ 13:21

6. WWF Intercontinental Champion Ricky Steamboat pinned Ron Starr @ 15:54

7. Rocky Johnson pinned Michael Hayes @ 11:32

8. NWA World Midget's Champion Little Tokyo pinned Tiger Jackson @ 9:00

9. Rick Martel pinned Ric Flair @ 37:32

In real life:

1 Bob Marcus defeated Masanobu Fuchi

2 Jacques Goulet and Kelly Kiniski defeated Vinnie Valentino and Nick DeCarlo

3 One Man Gang defeated Mike Davis

4 Dory Funk Jr. defeated Mike Rotundo (23:04 minutes)

5 Rufus R. Jones defeated Jake Roberts

6 Greg Valentine defeated Cy Jernigan (9:16 minutes)

7 Jack Brisco and Jerry Brisco defeated Ricky Steamboat and Jay Youngblood by disqualification (18:22 minutes)

8 Steel Cage Match

Jimmy Valiant and Bob Orton Jr. defeated The Great Kabuki and Gary Hart

9 NWA Canadian Heavyweight Title (Toronto-Version) Match

Sgt. Slaughter defeated Angelo Mosca © (22:18 minutes) - TITLE CHANGE!!!

10 NWA World Heavyweight Title Match

Harley Race © defeated Ric Flair by disqualification (16:42 minutes)

 

 

Wow, another close one. Unfortunately I have to choose real life just because of personal preference, but again just by a hair. I wonder how the real life Dory Funk vs Mike Rotundo match compared to the classic match Smelzer reviewed?

[goc]

I thought Ricky Steamboat wasn't allowed to wrestle that total scrub no one has ever heard of?

[Flyin' Brian]

lol I missed that one. Dark match?

[Grimmas]

Lol. My results were original version..

[peachchaos]

Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada 8/10/83

 

Earth 2:
Kerry Brown & Bulldog Bob Brown def. Mike Hammer & Matt Borne @ 13:23
Gama Singh def. David Morgan @ 14:34
Bounty Hunter #2 def. Mr. Hito @ 4:56
Junji Hirata def. Hiro Saito @ 22:38
Archie Gouldie def. Dynamite Kid @ 13:56
No DQ: Bret Hart & Jim Neidhart def. Jerry Blackwell & Bounty Hunter #1 @ 19:34
The Cobra def. Davey Boy Smith @ 29:14

 

Original:

Coconut Willie defeats Wolfman Kevin
Ben Bassarab & Steve Logan defeat Athol Foley & Danny Babich
Cuban Assassin defeats Don Kolov
Francisco Flores defeats Shunji Takano
Hercules Ayala defeats Ciclon Negro
Cobra & Hiro Saito defeat Bruce Hart & Davey Boy Smith
Jim Neidhart defeats Bad News Allen by DQ

[Flyin' Brian]

  On 8/10/2015 at 4:22 PM, peachchaos said:

Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada 8/10/83

 

Earth 2:

Kerry Brown & Bulldog Bob Brown def. Mike Hammer & Matt Borne @ 13:23

Gama Singh def. David Morgan @ 14:34

Bounty Hunter #2 def. Mr. Hito @ 4:56

Junji Hirata def. Hiro Saito @ 22:38

Archie Gouldie def. Dynamite Kid @ 13:56

No DQ: Bret Hart & Jim Neidhart def. Jerry Blackwell & Bounty Hunter #1 @ 19:34

The Cobra def. Davey Boy Smith @ 29:14

 

Original:

Coconut Willie defeats Wolfman Kevin

Ben Bassarab & Steve Logan defeat Athol Foley & Danny Babich

Cuban Assassin defeats Don Kolov

Francisco Flores defeats Shunji Takano

Hercules Ayala defeats Ciclon Negro

Cobra & Hiro Saito defeat Bruce Hart & Davey Boy Smith

Jim Neidhart defeats Bad News Allen by DQ

 

Tie.