Jump to content
Pro Wrestling Only

Cactus Watches Every Wrestlemania - 1-32 Reviewed!


cactus

Recommended Posts

As lockdown has given me a shedload of free time, I decided to watch all the Wrestlemanias in order. I've been posting my individual match reviews in the PWO database, but I thought it would be a good idea to get them all together here with some additional comments about the events themselves and I'll do a top 25/50/whatever off my all-time 'Mania matches once I'm nearly up to date. This is still a WIP, but let feel free to drop comments/feedback. 

1 - 15

  Reveal hidden contents

16 - 30

  Reveal hidden contents

31 - Present

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The first two stand best as curios of where the company was in terms of transitioning from a regional company to a national one. A lot of trial and error, especially with the 2nd one, as how to really pull a big show off. Hulkamania running wild in NYC with Cyndi Lauper and the Rock & Wrestling era was the birth of the vision. WrestleMania 3 is the realization of it, and also the beginning of Vince wanting to make the company bigger than any one star. 

The booking of WrestleMania 1 is a bit odd to me in that they didn't have more blow-offs, specifically Santana/Valentine which was a hot feud. I get that they teased it quite a bit in both of their matches, but it's disappointing that one had to open the show and the other had to work the Junkyard Dog in light of the classics they had in that arena. 

2 is a bit of a hard watch, mostly for the guest commentators. They rectified this by having Bob Uecker yuck it up during two matches at 3 and 4. And while it comes across okay on video, it's my understanding the live feed was a bit of a clusterfuck, not having mastered the satellite hookup. I can imagine Vince watching Live Aid thinking he could do the same thing but across 3 cities, his ego not anticipating the problems even that show had putting it all together. About the only match with rewatchable quality is the battle royal, something I doubt they could ever pull off again. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 1/28/2021 at 4:41 PM, flyonthewall2983 said:

The first two stand best as curios of where the company was in terms of transitioning from a regional company to a national one. A lot of trial and error, especially with the 2nd one, as how to really pull a big show off. Hulkamania running wild in NYC with Cyndi Lauper and the Rock & Wrestling era was the birth of the vision. WrestleMania 3 is the realization of it, and also the beginning of Vince wanting to make the company bigger than any one star. 

The booking of WrestleMania 1 is a bit odd to me in that they didn't have more blow-offs, specifically Santana/Valentine which was a hot feud. I get that they teased it quite a bit in both of their matches, but it's disappointing that one had to open the show and the other had to work the Junkyard Dog in light of the classics they had in that arena. 

2 is a bit of a hard watch, mostly for the guest commentators. They rectified this by having Bob Uecker yuck it up during two matches at 3 and 4. And while it comes across okay on video, it's my understanding the live feed was a bit of a clusterfuck, not having mastered the satellite hookup. I can imagine Vince watching Live Aid thinking he could do the same thing but across 3 cities, his ego not anticipating the problems even that show had putting it all together. About the only match with rewatchable quality is the battle royal, something I doubt they could ever pull off again. 

Expand  

Yeah, it's clear that it took them a few years to find their feet. I guess that a Santana/Valentine match might end up overshadowing the marquee matches of 1. 

Update: That's the first seven 'Manias written up. I've watched and reviewed up to 21, so there's still plenty of work to be done!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 1/28/2021 at 4:41 PM, flyonthewall2983 said:

 I can imagine Vince watching Live Aid thinking he could do the same thing but across 3 cities, his ego not anticipating the problems even that show had putting it all together.

Expand  

I assume he was trying to one up Crockett, who had just done the first dual city Starrcade a few months earlier. Not just with the extra city but by doing a cross-country show in the three most important cities in America instead of just a few hundred miles in the southeast.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Also, there was still a bit of a "save it for the house shows" mentality at the time of the first Mania since it was a total gamble.  The show was drawing poorly until Hogan & T's guest spot on Saturday Night Live, IIRC, so i imagine they didn't want to risk major blowoff matches besides the women's title one.  Note that the US Express won the tag titles back not long after WM1, and the world title wasn't even on the line!

Also re: Race vs. JYD from WM3, Race was higher up on the card at that point so it made sense to give him the win then have the face get his heat back afterward.  FYI, Race would go on to a full house-show run vs. Hogan a month or two after WM3 - that year saw quite a few pre-Hulkamania stars going for those juicy paydays.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The first two Manias were all about generating mainstream publicity by loading the shows with celebrities. It's largely forgotten today, but WM3 didn't receive nearly as much media attention as the first two despite doing much bigger business. The Big Event changed the game by proving it was possible to set business records with just basic pro wrestling angles.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 1/30/2021 at 8:46 PM, Strummer said:

Hogan and Mr. T hosting SNL was actually the night before the first Mania. They were a last minute replacement for Steve Landesberg, who became ill earlier in the week

Expand  

Ah, thanks!  So before that, but i remember hearing it was still just the week before the show or so that they started really moving tickets.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 1/29/2021 at 3:50 PM, Ricky Jackson said:

They had run Tito vs Hammer I think 6 times at MSG prior to Mania, including a lumberjack match only a few weeks before. It was the right call to go with the fresh match here, even if it turned out to be a dud 

Expand  

That Lumberjack Match fucking rules, too.  They completely have that crowd believing the title change is taking place.  Highly recommended.

  On 1/30/2021 at 9:21 PM, funkdoc said:

Ah, thanks!  So before that, but i remember hearing it was still just the week before the show or so that they started really moving tickets.

Expand  

It was more the weekend of the show.  The Richard Belzer incident from a few days before gave them tons of free publicity too.  Most all of WrestleMania 1's closed circuit ticket sales came last minute, a large chunk of it Sunday.  WrestleMania 1 didn't even do a full sellout of the Garden!! They kinda just assumed it would sell out so they also sold tickets for the Felt Forum.

Also yeah the first WrestleMania was mainly about the idea of it being a spectacle and not really a way to settle TV feuds.  Don Muraco wasn't even on the show and in exchange he got to headline with Hulk for three straight MSG shows.  Not a bad tradeoff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This thread has made me realise that a lot of the WrestleManias I thoroughly enjoyed at the time were actually pretty meh shows. The hype around WrestleMania and the notion that it's "the Granddaddy of them all!" certainly consumes me when watching live but there's only a select few I could go back to now and come away with the opinion that it still holds up well. When it comes to reviewing the more recent shows, I can't say that I envy you at all to be honest man; while there's some good stuff here and there, the thought alone of having to endure 20+ hours over four shows is enough to drive me insane. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 11 months later...
  On 2/6/2022 at 12:49 PM, cactus said:

Thanks for the interest, but I really started to regret this project when I got up to the Wrestlemanias from the 2010s. Those shows drag, man. I can't see myself returning to this anytime soon. Maybe one day...

Expand  

I completely understand. Once you start creeping into 5 and 6 hour long shows, the dedication required is simply too much. Even if you have a 6 hour show full of 5 star matches, it'd still be a lot to handle - unfortunately though none of the WrestleManias that fit into that 5/6/7 hour long category can claim to be barn burners from the top to the bottom of the cards. WrestleMania 1 to 31 are shows that I would be happy to go back and watch, but I can't see myself ever going back and watching WrestleMania 32 onwards. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...