How to participate

[Justtxyank]

I have been a lurker and admirer of this group of commentators for years but only posted a few times. I’m curious about the criteria to be able to participate in this project. 

[Reel]

Post and then when 2026 comes around, Vote. Or don't post, just vote. No hurdles to clear. 

[Grimmas]

No critiera. Have fun and vote in 2026!

[Octopus]

Fellow lurker. I discovered the site after the last vote, so I’ve been reading everything after the fact. A few of the posters here I know from DVDVR, so I’m excited to participate. With a 1 year old at home, I may spread some posts out a bit. Saying that, hopefully I can contribute and learn. 

[Kain]

I've just browsed through the list of Nominees. Pretty extensive. At first glance I've not seen any omissions. I will put together a list for myself and do a more thorough check. If I were to nominate one I'd do it in the Nominees-Thread?

[HeadCheese]

2 hours ago, Kain said:

I've just browsed through the list of Nominees. Pretty extensive. At first glance I've not seen any omissions. I will put together a list for myself and do a more thorough check. If I were to nominate one I'd do it in the Nominees-Thread?

Yes! I think with 

"1) A small paragraph (3-5 sentences) that lay out their basic case.

2) A list of three recommended matches (with links if possible). "

You can have more than three match recommendations too

[Kain]

Thank you.

[Kain]

I've started to compile possible Candidates. Already about 300 Name. Always the feeling that I've missed someone. Even have some Lucha Guys on it, though I doubt they'll make my list. Strictly Lucha Guys I mean. I've excludes People that arguably should be on there when I either haven't seen enough of them or never in a concentrated way (like only a Match every few years or so) so that I don't feel I could competently rank them. One such example would be Bobo. Those decisions don't reflect on any given Persons greatness, of course.

[Superstar Sleeze]

So when is the deadline for voting? And how does one vote?

[El McKell]

People in the discord are working on that. The deadline for voting will likely be either May 5th or April 19th. With voting opening about 4 weeks in advance of the deadline
 

Voting will be probably be through google forms.

[El McKell]

On 1/19/2026 at 11:22 PM, Superstar Sleeze said:

So when is the deadline for voting? And how does one vote?

Confirmed deadline is May 5th. Ballot opens April 5th. All the nominations have to be in by March 5th.

[Superstar Sleeze]

14 hours ago, El McKell said:

Confirmed deadline is May 5th. Ballot opens April 5th. All the nominations have to be in by March 5th.

Thanks so much for keeping me in the loop. How do I submit a ballot? Discord aint my thing so I appreciate you keeping me updated. 

[bustedquad]

15 hours ago, El McKell said:

Confirmed deadline is May 5th. Ballot opens April 5th. All the nominations have to be in by March 5th.

Thank you for this! I’ve been monitoring this thread off and on for a while. Finally got my answer. 

[Ma Stump Puller]

2 hours ago, Superstar Sleeze said:

Thanks so much for keeping me in the loop. How do I submit a ballot? Discord aint my thing so I appreciate you keeping me updated. 

If you PM @Grimmas I'm sure they would be able to accommodate your list and add them to the others submitted. We don't have a official system set up yet, so don't worry!

 

[Grimmas]

4 hours ago, Superstar Sleeze said:

Thanks so much for keeping me in the loop. How do I submit a ballot? Discord aint my thing so I appreciate you keeping me updated. 

Ballots will be a google form link posted April 5th. I'll try to make it as easy as possible.

[Boss Rock]

22 hours ago, Grimmas said:

Ballots will be a google form link posted April 5th. I'll try to make it as easy as possible.

Thanks for the update!