Shawn Michaels v Chris Benoit - WWE RAW 05/03/04
First time I saw this when it aired live, I didn't think much of it at all. Someone must have spiked my drink with crack or something, because this was an awesome match, way better than I expected it to be when rewatching. The headlockery at the beginning is some of the better use of that spot I've seen in a WWE match and the build throughout is terrific. This match is definitely made-for-TV in that it's wrestled more like three 10-minute matches than one 30-minute one, so I don't think this layout would have worked on pay-per-view. Benoit is no-nonsense, though, and by proxy, some of the typical nonsense of his opponents gets left out of the game of his opponent because of the match layout -- there's no "oh-my-poor-back" selling, there's no no-sell kip up. It's just a battle of wills with each guy trying to outdo the other in any way possible. Favorite spots are Benoit's German suplex into a bridge (in WWE!!) and Shawn's Liontamer, which he should really use more often. There's silliness at the end with the ref bump and HHH making himself more important than the match, but this is probably Benoit's best match as champion and is definitely Shawn's best since returning in 2002.
***3/4 -- would have been higher with a clean finish. I normally don't really lower my opinion of the match enough to matter based on the finish, but with all the hype surrounding this, they really owed it to the fans to have a clear winner.