Phil Schneider

I called out Dean on the Marc Rocco lie on the podcast we did

Who were the dropoffs from the 2006 list?

Which means... i'm not sane or average? Doesn't it just mean that you define the word "objective" differently in this context? Hate to say it, but you seem pretty sane to me... Average? Let's not go there :-) I'm not average. Ask my wife. I am sure you have other good qualities, don't be so hard on yourself

I didn't have Psicosis on mine, and I really don't see an argument for him. He had a two year or so run in AAA and as a touring Rey partner, and had maybe 10 memorable matches in WCW and then two decades of nothing. I used to love the guy, but how can anyone put him in the top 100, much less top 50.

Psicosis and Juventud were so promising as really young wrestlers, while at the time I loved WCW signing all of these cool luchadores, in hindsight it just murdered their careers. Really only LA Park, the Villanos and Hector Garza had post WCW lucha careers.

Cool to see Honda make the top 250, I would rather watch Honda matches then almost anyone else in NOAH

Lothario, Ono and Mesias are all off my list. Matt is right about Lothario, the NWA classics stuff is a revelation, every time something new drops his rep improves. I would assume there is more out there, he was just an awesome ethnic regional babyface with classic brawl after classic brawl all appearing in the last six months or so.

Man that is a good argument, I really should have listened to that guy. I did rank Lothario though

Octogon being that high is totally weird, it means someone is a big lucha fan, but unable to notice when someone is a total bag of laundry being carried by better wrestlers. Also B-Boy? What the fuck?

Cool, Is the rest of that 1975 show available?

Wow Brisco v. Lothario would be really interesting to watch. We have discovered how awesome Jose was at brawls, it would be fascinating to see how he works in an long NWA title match style

So Will has been giving me shit about not putting Fargo on, I admit it maybe an oversight, but I guess the question is how much footage do you need to say someone is top 100. We really have very few Fargo matches that aren't severely clipped. He looks awesome and otherwordly in those clips, and I know if I had more I would love him, but he feels sort of like Johnny Valentine to me. Absolutely one of my guys, more footage he would be a no-brainer, but they are both just missing the evidence.

Surprised someone voted for Gilbert Cesca, I was considering it obviously (I nominated him) but he didn't make my final cut, hopefully French catch continues to disseminate, so guys are better represented next time

I am sure someone voted Kobashi #1, maybe one of those Disco Stu guys like El-P who are stuck in the 90s

Yeah thank goodness no one nominated that turd Chuck Taylor

Actually not always, I think 2 was better initially, but 1 surpassed him

Order of the Traumas seems wrong, I always thought 1 was clearly the better guy

I really should have found a place for Jackie Fargo somewhere

I wonder what the lowest placement of someone who got a #1 vote. Is someones #1 out of the top 100 entirely?

Posted mine

The Necro Butcher/Brodie Lee tags in JAPW were really great too, basically like new age Moondogs brawls

I will also watch it and give him a shot at my list

Out of guys not making your ballot, who would have the best 10 match or so greatest hits album, maybe not a guy with a long great career but some huge highs. Couple of guys I was thinking of. Steve Corino A lot of his career he was coasting on shtick, but if you look at his top matches you have some truly awesome stuff. His pair of Homicide matches in ROH (Better friends, stiffer enemies is maybe my favorite ROH match ever), the incredible Hashimoto/Corino/Knight/Steele 4-way, Tajiri ECW match. I just am not sure I can rate a guy with 8 or so classics and so much chaff Mil Muertes After last nights match, we are looking at four Lucha Underground classics and those pair of awesome LA Park brawls, that is a pretty high end. Not really sure what else is out there though.

Isn't that a 2015 match?

Has this match been out there before?