This is exactly how I am feeling right now. There have been other matches with worse action, but every single thing about this match was putrid. Absolutely irredeemable.
Not to regurgitate smark talking points from 10 years ago, but why would WWF look at E&C in 2000 and decide that Edge is the one to be pushed for any reason other than the fact that he is taller.
I think another thing that made it better for me was no commentary. Give me Taker trash-talking and ridiculously cheesy background music over Michael Cole screaming "THIS IS A WRESTLEMANIA MOMENT!!!" any day.
Also, Taker's character has really evolved in the last 30 years to where this iteration felt organic. Wyatt is cinematic often just for the sake of it. This boneyard match would have never worked had Taker not spent literally decades laying the groundwork for it.