Why did you pick Benoit over Eddy in 1994?
To be honest, I would choose anything Eddy did with Los Gringos or AAA that year over Benoit and his Super J Cup win anyday of the week.
At this moment in time, I'll go with Eddy in a walk. We had an argument at SNKT over definitive matches that define someone's career. Eddy has had so many. With Benoit, most people consider the JCup win the one true classic match of Benoit's career. Hell, I don't even think that match is one of the tope ten junior matches, much less a true classic.
In fact, I think the exact opposite is true when I see these phrases...
Eddy has absolutely destroyed Benoit's work in the last 2 years. This isn't to demean Benoit (although it will) but Eddie has been far and away the best wrestler in WWE for two years running.