I would say Major negatives most years!
For me, I would say he's great as a heel in 97, outside of the drug issues. He's a pretty good heel in 92, the rest of the time I think he's either off (like 93/94) or trying to find his way as a face and failing (95/96).
Ha, I was trying to look on the bright side.
1997 is definitely the front-runner. Also allows him to be either a face or heel.
The rest are my childhood favorites, especially late 94-96, yet will likely stay away from anything involving him dancing in the ring with children or wearing gaudy earrings.