Young Bucks vs Jimmy Valiant

[Champagne]

Loved by their fans and derided by their critics.

[strobogo]

I would vote for Malakai Jackson over Jimmy Valiant 

[El-P]

So, it's time for a troll poll already ? Ok. Let me do Jerry Lawler vs Art Barr then...

[Tetsujin]

I don't know who Jimmy Valiant is. I also voted for him.

[Reel]

which buck had a decent to good run in a best of the super juniors that made everybody say he was this great singles wrestler, i'd vote or him. 

[Tetsujin]

Nick is definitely better than Matt.

[El-P]

The tricky thing being to rate both while they really never work singles match. Let's say if I have Matt at #25, Nick has to be #24 indeed.

[Phil Schneider]

We don't have very much of prime Jimmy, his Boogie Woogie man stuff was probably in-ring post-prime. If you want the clips of this Lawler vs. Valiant match from 1981 he looks like an all time great brawler

 

 

[strobogo]

I've seen pre Boogie Woogie Man era and can confirm he was also dogshit then

[joeg]

In 1978ish my cousin beat up both of the Valiant Brothers at the same time at a hotel bar near the Cap Center. People complain that the Bucks don't look like/aren't built like people capable of handling themselves but appearantly neither could the Valiant Brothers. 

[justinsdrown]

Jimmy Valiant by far. Though I’m not a fan of The Young Bucks in general. I find myself struggling to care during most of their matches. They are the wrestling equivalent of Michael Bay.

[dkuchler31096]

I think the Bucks win this one hand down.

[Mr JMML]

On 6/20/2023 at 7:03 AM, justinsdrown said:

Jimmy Valiant by far. Though I’m not a fan of The Young Bucks in general. I find myself struggling to care during most of their matches. They are the wrestling equivalent of Michael Bay.

This is exactly how I feel about The Young Bucks.