So your argument is that he will be in every Hall of Fame except the one that places merit on drawing ability, which is the primary metric of the whole mega star thing. OK. Got it.
If Edge and Christian as a duo were to show up I think that would satisfy everyone's expectations, but that obviously isn't going to happen.
However, if he turns out to be the surprise guy in the ladder match (which would fit based on his legacy) I would have no problems with that.
I just can't see Tony, man of the people that he is, really thinking he can hype up Christian as a mega star signing and it not coming off as a disappointment.