EnviousStupid

I would put the Ogawa matches (excluding the shoot) and rivalry overall above Hash's stuff with Tenryu across the 90s. They were the peak of Inokiism and hold up tremendously well, even after the MMA craze that followed.

HACKSAW

I'd stick with Necro primarily for being a major part of the overarching CZW/ROH feud and having incredible work across multiple promotions compared to someone like Danielson. Rey is probably the most consistently great wrestler this year though. The title run isn't so fondly remembered, but goddamn if he wasn't delivering every time he worked on TV.

He's not the best in 93, but Hiroshi Hase had a fantastic run.

Joe and Kobashi are in the middle of all-time great world title reigns, along with Eddie Guerrero at arguably his best. Though I had to mention how incredible Randy Orton is in those Evolution tags and singles work against Foley and Benoit especially. It was like seeing a future GOAT and it sucks that he never fully turned out that way.

For my money, Foley had a MOTYC with all three of his gimmicks in 1998. Also had an incredibly fun team with Chainsaw Charlie for the first few months. Genichiro Tenryu is also pretty fantastic this year, as is Shinya Hashimoto with one of the best G1 runs ever. Need to see more from Santo but if the Felino match is any indicator, he's also in the conversation.

Not a favourite, but he's almost certainly the best wrestler of the 2000s in my eyes, and that's the decade I grew up watching wrestling in. Plenty of great stuff across singles, tags, multimans, main-events, undercards, sprints, 30+ minute epics and practically everything in between. He even participated in one of the best G1 Climax tournaments, concluding with an all-time finals match against Hiroyoshi Tenzan.

Steamboat stopped wrestling in 1994. If Rey is still active come 2026 his career will have covered twice the amount of time Steamboat's did. That might not matter to some, but I think the body of work is comfortably in Rey's favor. More situations, more settings, more opponents, more great matches and performances in general, almost all of which took place outside of WWE's best years

What is Bryan's peak work in tag settings? Excluding the big gimmick matches like Anarchy in the Arena or Cage of Death, I don't know if his best is in the six-mans opposite The Shield or if there's some major tags from the indies I'm forgetting. I'd love to see how it compares to someone like Terry, where a lot of their All Japan work is in tags and with him regularly putting on the best performances in those matches.

I feel like the lesser of great tag teams who never really went away to become singles stars are almost bound to be omitted in ballots, whereas their better halves gain all the credit. I know there's a couple title matches with Flair in 86, but does anyone know of other worthwhile singles work from Gibson?

I'm now of the opinion that Ogawa was Hashimoto's best opponent, and that their rivalry across the late 90s-2000 is an all-timer.

With almost every match I see from her Stardom run, the more I feel inclined to call her the best joshi ace I've ever seen, and that's against the likes of Aja Kong, Bull Nakano, Chigusa Nagayo. For the qualities and ability that kind of role asks from a wrestler, I think that Io covers the most ground.

I just think Punk has far greater highs, consistency, variety, adaptability, match layout, character work, rivalries, etc. over his career. Even in 2009, when Jericho had the big rivalry with Mysterio - arguably the BITW that year - Punk was getting quality stuff out of Jeff Hardy and The Undertaker. Then he went on to lead one of the best stables of that era and have a great feud with Mysterio the following year.

My expectations going into this were extremely low, knowing that both are well past their primes and how these two can tend to phone it in, but I completely dug what they were going for here. It's a match that takes into account their physical limitations and builds off of their collective charisma to make all the sparks and quick bursts (particularly from Mutoh) hold much more significance than usual. The matwork and limb targeting early on is kept to a minimum and that's for the best: Mutoh's a great face when his sporadic choices in pacing and offense come off like a necessary reaction to his opponents. Chono can't work like Vader in 1991, but somewhere along the lines of an older Tenryu is possible and that's the feeling I got while watching this. Chono is in control most of the time and is usually able to shut down those moments of hope from the champion and be disrespectful as hell while doing so. It's one of the few times I can recall finishers being blocked instead of just countered or avoided. The match also plays on the more recent parts of their rivalry; Chono had beaten Mutoh earlier in the year as well as the year prior, both times submitting to the STF. They milk that a couple times in the finishing stretch, however it's Chono's insistence of never really trying to win quickly that left the biggest impression. He knows that this matchup has been in his favor these last few years, so he's not rushing to a pin after most of his Yazuka Kicks land their mark. By giving Mutoh enough time to recover, he's quick and still agile enough to perform a flash Frankensteiner to snatch the win. Not a MOTYC, but it's one that I felt strongly enough about to post here.

That's awesome. Even though I'm a fan, Chono's always been a case of what could've been had he not suffered that neck injury early in his career, as until that point he would've probably been my favourite of the Musketeers. I always remember how in those early G1 final matches, he worked the finishes as though he were capitalizing on opportune moments to barely come away with the victory, which was really distinct from how most other heavyweights would go about their matches.

Watched this on a whim and once again I'm left thinking Orton is one of the greatest sellers in wrestling history. I could see some faulting him for a lack of fire here, but there's just so many minute details to his reactions and gait that it makes up for never really excelling as a face for me. Add in how rougher and less contrived this felt compared to standard TV wrestling, and it makes the work put in from both men stand out that much more.

I've worked myself into really digging this card, even though I do not care about the build for all of them. It's nice to see so many of the young, homegrown talent getting PPV matches against big names established elsewhere, and that so many of them have a decent shot of winning.

Watched this for the first time since it happened live and I feel roughly the same way about it as I do for the Ric Flair/Ricky Steamboat Spring Stampede match in 94. The attire of both champs dictates what the story will be. Unlike Flair though, Punk has no need to fight past demons and history from repeating itself. He won the title from Cena as the ultimate hometown underdog the year before at Money in the Bank, then won again at the following PPV. The rivalry has been in Punk's favor for a while now, so wearing Yankees-themed trunks in Boston is not only an incredibly heelish move, but one putting their feud into perspective. Punk is the dynasty here and has no problem showboating about it. He can still back it up in the ring though. The guy has Cena scouted like few others, having an answer for practically all of Cena's moves and attempted comebacks. Once Cena does get time to work on top, he's compelled enough to think outside the box, like going for a Tope or ditching the typical theatrics because of how they gave Punk the chance to counter earlier. Much like the aforementioned Flair/Steamboat bout, the finish is a double-pin where the babyface looked like they should've won, except they weren't able to properly capitalize on the opportunity. For Steamboat, it was not being strong enough late in the match to hold a bridge with a Double Chickenwing ala Clash of the Champions 1989, but here it's Cena going out of his wheelhouse again with a German Suplex off the ropes, either forgetting to bridge or not realizing where his shoulders are during the pin.

Honestly fair. Seeing his shtick so often last year also left a sour taste in my mouth and there's plenty of other wrestlers that I do prefer. I just feel that when looking at the volume and consistency of his output over these last three years, it's hard for most to compare.

Best wrestler of the 2020s so far? He's arguably the consensus WOTY for both 2020 and 2022 with plenty of great matches in AEW, as well as some across the occasional NJPW and indie show he's on.

GWE 2016 was the best time for Nakamura to have a place in many people's ballots. I suspect most were only following the major stuff from New Japan and when a match called for Shinsuke to turn it on, he was clearly one of the best in the world. But excluding that top end material, a lot of the time he was coasting off of his undeniable charisma and while that's not a dealbreaker for a project like this, it is something that gets exposed quickly in a weekly TV setting like WWE.

GWE 2016 was the best time for Nakamura to have a place in many people's ballots. I suspect most were only following the major stuff from New Japan and when a match called for Shinsuke to turn it on, he was clearly one of the best in the world. But excluding that top end material, a lot of the time he was coasting off of his undeniable charisma and while that's not a dealbreaker for a project like this, it is something that gets exposed quickly in a weekly TV setting like WWE.

It's not a long run and she was never the flashiest, but she's easily one of my favourites of the 90s joshi scene. Did a lot of deathmatches, however something like the title match with Aja Kong at St. Battle stands out for how well she can adapt as this invader who is dwarfed in stature and manages to balance a fine line between getting slapped around so much, while still posing a threat to Aja as she goes after the arm.

Surprised that Shinya Hashimoto's name hasn't popped up. Had an incredible run in the 98 G1 Climax, with plenty of great matches spread across other G1s that decade. That's not including the big IWGP Heavyweight Title Dome Show in 1989. Recommended matches include: vs Victor Zangiev & Big Van Vader (24/04/89) vs Masahiro Chono (11/08/91) vs Hiroshi Hase (03/08/93) vs Kensuke Sasaki (12/08/95) & vs Keiji Mutoh (15/08/95) vs Riki Choshu (02/08/96) vs Genichiro Tenryu (01/08/98) & vs Kazuo Yamazaki (02/08/98)

In some ways, I find it the inverse of Sting/Hogan Starrcade 97, which had an incredible build spanning over a year to get to their big payoff, only to not deliver anything close to expectation. This match had the story that Sting/Hogan should've had, with all the physicality and overbooking to stack the odds against Sting, before the true ace stands tall. Was it worth the months the dogshit TNA fed their fans over the Aces & Eights angle? Absolutely fucking not. It's part of the reason I consider 2013 among the worst years of the company. But as for the destination to this journey, it hit a sweet spot, accompanied with an outrageous performance from AJ. No two ways about, he had dat dawg in 'im.