This thread is one of the more frustrating to read on the board. Most of the reasons given for not liking Jumbo are exterior(this jealous peer gave this account), based on obfuscated “vibes”(I don’t like his aura),or critiques that don’t match the footage. It’s telling that those who heavily criticize Tsuruta tend to pair these criticisms with the fact that they don’t ever watch his work.
Jumbo mastered three distinct styles. But he also defied formula. Instead adapting to his opponents. Jumbo’s rookie years being described as only “competent” by some users here is a hilarious understatement. Compare his early work with Misawa putting out his worst output dogging it as Tiger Mask II.
Not only that but he was a better seller than Masawa. And more fundamentally sound than any of The Four Pillars. There was a great X/Twitter post I read that there is a formula to popular accepted 5 Star “bangers” and once you recognize this formula wrestling becomes boring. Jumbo owes some blame in helping innovate the BIG MOVE, FALSE FINISH, BIG MOVE, FALSE FINISH style match in the mid-late 80s. It was The Four Pillars who beat that particular horse far beyond death.
Jumbo Tsuruta was a far more varied and interesting worker than he’s sometimes given credit for in this thread. The footage shows this. In my mind, where others view him as a boring pick, I view Jumbo as an ideal Puro Ace. It’s the same feeling I have for El Hijo del Santo for Lucha, Juguar Yokota for Joshi, and Thesz or Funk for American Wrestling. He’s among a small handful of workers I find endlessly rewatchable.