Real compelling arguments by Elliot and Dylan. I have started with the Rose set and damn he was great. There is a huge battle in the 7-26 range. At this second Rose is winning that battle.
I really loved the show! Motivated Tim and I do put out our full 100 lists, as well.
What I really took out of it was how much Chad & Parv value output compared to myself values how talented someone is more. Love all the different ways that people are going about their lists.
calculated as average of the ones voted for.
By the way I am geeking out on results right now. It's so fascinating! We are sitting at 34 ballots with lots of pledged voters who have not turned them in (dylan, will, chad, tim, matt d, myself, etc...)
Just in case there is a tie in points, what should we do? There is none right now, but some spots are very close. Including the number one spot.
Figured this should be up for discussion.
He's on my tentative list. He may drop off, but if I had to submit today he would make it. He'll be in the 90s, though. Too many all time great matches and performances to dismiss.
He's sort of like a mini-Sgt Slaughter in terms of being a greatest hits candidate. But Khan is a ten-track single disc and Slaughter is a double-disc duluxe set with a couple of hidden gem album tracks out there too.
Seems fair. Slaughter is on my list and higher.
He's on my tentative list. He may drop off, but if I had to submit today he would make it. He'll be in the 90s, though. Too many all time great matches and performances to dismiss.
This show convinced me to rank some guys that I was throwing out, because they were still good today. Guys like Hero, Low Ki, Cersaro, Sami Zayn all now have a shot at my list. Thanks Parv and Chad, you just made this harder.
I've been thinking that Eddie may do insanely well for me. In 94, 97 and 05 he had an all-time great heel run. In 04 had was all-time great babyface. 94, 97, 04 he had matches that were top 50 all-time. He could do great brawls, great technical matches and great spot fests. He really is one of the most complete wrestlers of all-time.