Matt D

Unfortunately Christian isn't making the top 30. Not for lack of trying.

We don't disagree in a lot of ways, and it's enough to get him into my top 30. It, along with other aspects of his WWE work, good and bad, will get him that far but maybe not into the top 20 anymore. "Better than it had any right to be" takes you far, just not as far as it could, you know?

I've been watching a bit recently and I think he's falling down my list. I had him in the 15-20 range at one point. I don't think he'll make it lower than 30 (maybe not even 25), but I'm nonplussed lately. I think I'm just less favorable towards the super-indy style than others. What I can say is that he makes me at time, not love it, but like it, and that in and of itself is impressive. I watched a match tonight where the first five minutes were very good, full of character and story and the closing was very smart, and the middle was a lot of big moves and strikes rushed through from both guys. And he wasn't wrestling a schlub. The Flair comparison is interesting because with both wrestlers, I tend to like individual parts of their matches more than the greater whole. In both cases, however, I can only hold it so far against them because it's probably what they should have been doing for the crowds they were in front of. But I'll hold it far enough for it to be a few slots here and there on a list of the best ever.

I don't think a lot of people have him in their top 15.

I THINK this is Paraguay? But I have no idea. I don't think it's Argentinian Titanes. My favorite stuff starts at the 17:30 mark. Tony Luciano is TREMENDOUS.

Earnest post and it deserves a response, and probably better than the general one I'm going to give. I love "Learned Psychology" too, and think it's probably the very best thing of this age of oversaturation. It's why Punk will be on my list, as much as anything else, and why I'll be higher than almost anyone on Christian. Really, all of the modern WWE workers I have will be on there, in part, for being good at that. It's a hugely important part of TV matches. With Kofi, however, I feel like we see the strings far too clearly. Some of that has to do with who he has been paired with the most, but only part. There's an art to that level of creativity and continuity in match layout, but it has to be mixed with spontaneity and believability in execution. Maybe it's Kofi's physical grace. Maybe it's a side effect of his specific moves and the level of cooperation involved with some of them, but I see the strings too clearly in his matches. They come off as more choreographed than the people who work in that specific element who will fall on my list. It never feels natural and organic to me. It's a fine line and he doesn't even come close to making it onto the right side, to me. I get what you're saying and I can go on that trip with other wrestlers, and do gladly, but not with Kofi.

Judy Martin from my microscope thread. "No Class" Bobby Bass per various old Wrestling Cultures, this post on DVDVR, and something Dylan will add in to fill in the gap.

I have them three apart. That may change. Bret is higher.

Personally, it doesn't matter at all to me, except for in thinking how much easier Flair had it relative to the type of guys Bryan had to face. Flair jokes about 2-3 terrible wrestlers he had to face as champion, and even those were good enough or had certain tools that made them a top guy in a territory that drew X number of people on a loop. To me, Flair's greatest strength and his greatest weakness are the same thing, total and utter conviction in the idea of Ric Flair. He's not someone who would look under the hood because he was the absolute. He defined what good wrestling was so it became a self-referential loop. That's evident in his work and it's one reason why he's so engrossing. His belief was off the chart. His "method" was the easiest thing in the world, because he was Ric Flair and there was nothing he wanted more than to be Ric Flair. Bryan thought and occasionally overthought things. There was a match between he and Punk where they cycled in a spot from some recent MMA fight. This wasn't a a house show where they were just having fun. It was either on a Raw or (I think) on PPV, for the World title. I'm sure Dave probably loved in for how "topical" it was, but it's the sort of thing Flair would have never done, because he would have thought that what he was providing anyway, the Ric Flair package, was worth more than that in the first place. And there are pros and cons to that approach. That's the biggest difference between the two to me, though. Bryan looked under the hood. Sometimes that was a good thing. Sometimes it wasn't. (And in his last run he absolutely didn't, so that's interesting too). Flair felt he didn't have to and that confidence is evident in his work.

That's a dangerous slippery slope, especially re: let's say Cena and Arn Anderson.

I strongly disagree with this still. I think it's much different for a relatively undersized, technical babyface to win with these. To me, as a kid, and even now, it came off as Bret being "technical." He was skilled enough to lock in quick roll ups out of nowhere and what have you. That fit his gimmick very well and made him seem more clever and more dangerous in a wrestling sense, as if he could beat you more ways than someone like Hogan, who was only going to win with the Legdrop. Bret could win with "Wrestling."

No.

Have you been watching Buddy Rose at all, Parv?

I will not have Bossman above Dibiase, in case anyone was concerned.

The problem is that he was booked as a coward out of the gate. Fans were turning on him for the first time. I think a Kane feud made a lot of sense on paper. This didn't: I think it's extremely obvious in retrospect and it's been written in the Observer and elsewhere that Bryan was only getting the reluctant nod so that Lesnar could destroy him at Mania on the path to the eventual Reigns win. He was going to be a transitional champion.

Now someone tie this information to explain Adam Rose's main roster debut.

Or this:

This was linked off of the CNN.com main page: Kevin Dunn Executive Producer $4.8 million George Barrios Chief Financial and Strategy Officer $4.5 million Michelle Wilson Chief Revenue and Marketing Officer $4.5 million Vince McMahon Chairman and CEO $3.3 million Paul "Triple H" Levesque Executive Vice President of Talent, Live Events and Creative $3.1 million

You'd need the big names in matches people haven't seen. There are a couple of Andre matches, vs Spoiler and Stasiak I think. There's Harley vs Gino for the title. There's the Duggan/Dibiase cage match. There's the RnR vs Midnights match that was new to us, I think? There's a couple of Jake matches to choose from. One Dusty (Maybe the Lewin one, but the Funk vs Lewin one could be better), one JYD vs Reed. You want at least one Guerrero (or Guerreros) match to pay up on the name and there are a lot to choose from. That's the way I'd go. Then try to get someone to do liner notes to give everything some context and show the importance. Maybe see if JR or Cornette would push it on his podcast, that kind of thing.

What resonates with me the most is when he's selling a beating on the floor, maybe between falls, or just in the midst of a beatdown, and he's leaning on the apron. Sometimes a kid will come up and interact with him. I've seen it a few times now and it's just transcendent somehow, like he's channeling a higher level of wrestling reality that no one else can reach.

He is my first heart over brains candidate.

Cena having great tag team matches with The Shield and others and being a surprisingly good FIP, as Phil Rippa pointed out today, gets him a point. This, apparently, does not get JBL one:

There's such a discrepancy between him as a babyface and a heel.

He's in my top 20. I have 3-4 above him, depending on how you classify Rey.

Cubsfan posted this comment yesterday: 6) Ephesto, Luciferno, Mephisto © bBlue Panther, Blue Panther Jr., The Panther [MEX TRIOS] 13:24. Hijo del Infierno took 2/3 in a very good match. Hijos del Infierno 3rd defense Main event is the match worth watching; they worked very hard and they had the usual Blue Panther creativity in match layout. Someone actually on twitter should try to get him to expand those thoughts a little. It's not something that's been talked about here at all.