Death From Above... I'm a journalist, so that's not what I'm saying. I've certainly never played college football (thank God, I probably would've been killed) but I write about it every single day for 9 months out of the year. I understand those who can't do still can have knowledge and certainly right to criticize. An educated or well-versed observer certainly can identify what works, and what sucks.
However, I don't think the wrestling the Meltzers of the world enjoy represents what Joe Wrestlingfan wants to see.
You have to know your audience, and be able to present what they want to see. Not sure the dot-com guys would be capable of doing that for a promotion that caters to the masses. The smarks would dig it, but that's a very small percentage of the audience.
The same criticisms also could be made of current big-league promotions, given the significant dropoff in viewership of the former and the significant portion of the wrestling fan audience that seemingly disappeared when WCW went away.
I'm probably rambling now, so I'll just stop here.