Why does that matter if they're not running the same town every night?
3. What happens when it is the same town in 2 months' time? And again in 4 months' time? And again in 6 months? In a way Memphis is a total mystery to me and it's a minor miracle that kept people coming back to the same place week after week -- I don't know what their mixing up the guys to "new meat" ratio was like.* But in any case JCP wasn't Memphis, it was a national promotion and WWF was the competition. It's not just towns but TV too.
Its not just Memphis. Its every single territory that wasn't national but running the same town or local region every week. If you want to say that by late '87 or '88 JCP was slipping and say it was due to repetitive booking on top and a lack of fresh matchups, that's fine. But that's after 3-4 years, and not a point that holds at any point in '85 or '86.
This. Even if you contend that the career resume of WWF's roster in the 80s may have been superior to JCP's, that is wholly irrelevant. It can only be examined in context for. that. specific. period. If Flair and Funk were to go and put out an awful match, you can't tout it as a classic because that's what their careers would have you think.