OK, here is my concern, and I encountered it in the MOTYC discs I have been making. Are we really concerned about the best matches or is this just an excuse to acquire more footage? I tried to be as inclusive as possible and my little 2-3 disc project ballooned to 6 discs and it is still growing. Hell, I don't even think anyone is that interested in it except me and Famous Mortimer anyways. If we do that here, we will be distributing 40 discs per category.
Looking through the previous lists, it seems like people were just naming off perceived 4-star matches, not actual BEST MATCH EVER candidates. That is why I have a hard time accepting ECW having its own category. They don't really have any Best Match candidates. If we want this to be manageable, we should be a little more exclusive on the matches that would be accepted. If people want to throw out matches then they should be willing to defend their choice with a reasoned and well-written post. If not, it's just listing matches for the sake of listing matches.