Jump to content
Pro Wrestling Only

Recommended Posts

Posted

I loved NO LIMIT, and junior tag wrestling is hardly my favourite thing. I think he was really good as a heavyweight before the injury. It slowed him down and despite occasionally putting on really good stuff it took him a while to really find himself. His new character is amazing and probably salvaged his career. Not a contender for me this time around but a guy I quite like.

  • 5 years later...
Posted

2016-onwards Naito has consistently one of the best in the world. His 2018-2019 had a few rocky outings due to suffering from double-vision, but he would still pull out some pretty high-caliber matches when called upon it. His 2020 was mostly disappointing due to being stuck with EVIL for most of the year, but he had a largely great G1 to make up for it and of course the MOTYC with Okada. I've enjoyed a few of his Stardust Genius matches pre-2015 but need to do a deeper dive on that period. That will probably determine if he's a top 50 candidate or "just" a lock somewhere on the ballot.

Posted

I would compare the pre-post LIJ Naito to pre-post CMLL run for Nakamura, but not quite as extreme. Pre LIJ Naito probably had a better resume of more exciting matches than pre coke Nak, but he was a similar quite dry good wrestler guy but with more focus on speedy spots/flying stuff as opposed to old strong style stuff.

 

If you're really into 2015-2016 Naito, idk what to suggest for his prior stuff as that was the biggest year of change in his style and then he slowly blended his old style with the new style as he got more popular with audiences again.

Posted
13 minutes ago, Boss Rock said:

The 42nd Anniversary Show match against Okada is probably my pick for best pre-LIJ Naito, at least based on what I've seen. A really good babyface performance. 

He had an excellent match at i 2011 G1 Finals with Nakamura. I'd put it just below the Okada match for best pre-LIJ Naito match. 

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

He's pretty good to great for more than a handful of years, and for 2-3 years was easily one of the best in the world and arguably the most over wrestler in NJPW. Great IC champion. Had pretty strong feuds with some of the top guys of the last decade. Has shown a wide range of roles he can play well in the last few G1 Climax tournaments. The Double champion runs last year weren't good but I blame that on circumstances related to COVID than him failing as the top guy. I'll need to check out more of his tag work from NO LIMIT but what I have seen I've enjoyed a lot. 

Posted

The following is what I wrote about Naito as a top 10/ contender on the GWE Project forum. He's one of my favourite wrestlers ever.

We all know his peak stuff (16-17) is absolutely incredible, as he was easily one of the best un the world and producing some of the best wrestling matches of the 10s, some of them arguably among the greatest ever (the Tanahashi 2017 trilogy, the first Omega match). In that period, and still today, he's one of the most consistent guys in current New Japan, having a lot of 'from very good to great' matches against very different opponents and kind of matches: vs Shingo, vs Taichi, vs Moxley, vs Ishii, vs White, vs Ibushi, more against Omega, vs Shibata, vs Styles, vs Jericho, the infamous WK 12 main event, vs Juice... As you can see, not all of those are top tier workers and, even though Naito always had his classic spots in mind everytime, he managed to insert them without feeling it unnatural despite how the match was going to be.

 

But I gotta say, a peak from 2016 to 2017 is a two-year peak only, and there are a lot of workers with a larger and more diverse peak. I'm not saying Naito is on their league, at least not from a "peak" perspective. Some other things I love about him is how he always projects his persona, in a way that everything he does, it feels like the correct thing El Ingobernable Tetsuya Naito would do. He might be in that "larger than life" character tier with guys like Hokuto, Funk or Hansen, because of his fantastic character work and amazing charisma.

 

And, I gotta, say, is pre-Ingobernable stuff is pretty great top, clearly underrated. In the first half of the 10s you have great and even amazing stuff with Ishii, Tanahashi, peak Okada, YUJIRO TAKAHASHI, the WK 9 Styles match... His character was kinda dull back then, but he was already at a high level of work, both on a regular basis and in top tier matches, but obviously he needed that Ingobernable transformation to became the best version of himself.

 

Throughout his whole career, Naito became also one of my favourite offensive wrestlers on the modern era, not because he's stiff (he's not), or because he's spotty (he is sometimes), but because he uses every part of his offensive game with a purpose. He doesn't spam things, he always do the right stuff when it has sense for him to do it. For example, his beautiful flying forearm smash or his spinebuster are great counters to his rival's momentum. He have great neck-based offense, setting up his bigger moves. The Destino literally was born as the perfect counter for the Rainmaker. I appreciate a lot stuff like that.

 

I think a case can be made about Naito being one of the best workers of the 10s, and to me it's early to consider him a top 100 ever contender, but his career looks great from today's perspective and I think he could be at the bottom of my GWE list in 2026 or 2036. We'll see. But I'm curious about what do you guys think.

  • 4 years later...
Posted
On 4/28/2021 at 1:02 AM, Tetsujin said:

The following is what I wrote about Naito as a top 10/ contender on the GWE Project forum. He's one of my favourite wrestlers ever.

We all know his peak stuff (16-17) is absolutely incredible, as he was easily one of the best un the world and producing some of the best wrestling matches of the 10s, some of them arguably among the greatest ever (the Tanahashi 2017 trilogy, the first Omega match). In that period, and still today, he's one of the most consistent guys in current New Japan, having a lot of 'from very good to great' matches against very different opponents and kind of matches: vs Shingo, vs Taichi, vs Moxley, vs Ishii, vs White, vs Ibushi, more against Omega, vs Shibata, vs Styles, vs Jericho, the infamous WK 12 main event, vs Juice... As you can see, not all of those are top tier workers and, even though Naito always had his classic spots in mind everytime, he managed to insert them without feeling it unnatural despite how the match was going to be.

 

But I gotta say, a peak from 2016 to 2017 is a two-year peak only, and there are a lot of workers with a larger and more diverse peak. I'm not saying Naito is on their league, at least not from a "peak" perspective. Some other things I love about him is how he always projects his persona, in a way that everything he does, it feels like the correct thing El Ingobernable Tetsuya Naito would do. He might be in that "larger than life" character tier with guys like Hokuto, Funk or Hansen, because of his fantastic character work and amazing charisma.

 

And, I gotta, say, is pre-Ingobernable stuff is pretty great top, clearly underrated. In the first half of the 10s you have great and even amazing stuff with Ishii, Tanahashi, peak Okada, YUJIRO TAKAHASHI, the WK 9 Styles match... His character was kinda dull back then, but he was already at a high level of work, both on a regular basis and in top tier matches, but obviously he needed that Ingobernable transformation to became the best version of himself.

 

Throughout his whole career, Naito became also one of my favourite offensive wrestlers on the modern era, not because he's stiff (he's not), or because he's spotty (he is sometimes), but because he uses every part of his offensive game with a purpose. He doesn't spam things, he always do the right stuff when it has sense for him to do it. For example, his beautiful flying forearm smash or his spinebuster are great counters to his rival's momentum. He have great neck-based offense, setting up his bigger moves. The Destino literally was born as the perfect counter for the Rainmaker. I appreciate a lot stuff like that.

 

I think a case can be made about Naito being one of the best workers of the 10s, and to me it's early to consider him a top 100 ever contender, but his career looks great from today's perspective and I think he could be at the bottom of my GWE list in 2026 or 2036. We'll see. But I'm curious about what do you guys think.

Four years later, I keep my words. Even when starting to break down and with COVID heavily affecting my enjoyment of NJPW as a whole, he has had amazing matches and performances like the Ospreay and Okada G1 bouts, the recent O Khan and ZSJ matches, an impressive carryjob to fucking Hikuleo, the Hiromu tag against Taichi and Ishii, even his last match with broken down Tanahashi was great. This guy is an all timer.

Posted

This is a guy who's reputation may be taking a hit based on the last few years, as a lot of people have expressed distaste with his matches as he's gotten older and physically broken down but to be frank, I feel even more conviction about his greatness now.

With a rapidly failing body, while certainly not as consistent as his prime years, I still found Tetsuya Naito to be one of the more compelling wrestlers of the 2020s. His strength has always been his eye for psychology and deliberate match layouts so while the physical decline was visible, I still loved a lot of his work. Even in his athletic prime, his matches oftentimes would have sequences break down, botches would occur, he has never been the "cleanest" worker in the conventional sense but his matches tend to always convey a sense of struggle. He has also smartly adjusted by often making his aging and injuries a narrative hook in his matches.

Just in recent memory, there is his double-shot vs. Will Ospreay and Kazuchika Okada back-to-back nights at the end of the 2023 G1 Climax which are both among the best matches I've seen in Japan this decade. His performance in Keiji Muto's retirement match helped make it every bit of the emotional, cathartic spectacle it needed to be.

This guy was called "Stardust Genius" early in his career because he was considered among his peers to have a generational talent for structuring matches and when you survey the last 15 years of New Japan, it becomes clear that Naito is in command of largely all of his matches, even ones against top vets like Tanahashi and Okada. 

What stands out about him is the grit and edge that he often applies to his work. There is an overt viciousness to the way that he will apply offense like headdrops and neck-focused manuevers in a way you just don't see much in modern wrestling contexts. He's not afraid to bleed or get in hateful brawls, the Jericho matches stand out as a different feel from anything you'd see in the promotion at the time, feels genuinely raw and unhinged at times. As a babyface, he is an all-time sympathetic seller and as a heel, can stooge and make a babyface look incredible by throwing himself into key offense while demonstrating more than sufficient malice and cruelty in control.

As far as I am concerned, he has produced genuinely notable and distinctly great matches at some point in his career against a laundry list of different opponents (some of whom are very flawed or limited workers): Okada, Omega, Ibushi, Tanahashi, Ishii, Shibata, Nakamura, Shingo, Zack Sabre Jr., Ospreay, Chris Jericho, AJ Styles, Juice Robinson, Taichi, Goto, Tenzan, Makabe, Muto, KENTA, Jeff Cobb, Lance Archer, EVIL, SANADA, YOSHI-HASHI, Mike Elgin, etc. and there is a clear variety to the scope of this work and the kind of stories told in these matches. He is a clear driver conceptually in all of them.

He also works in a tag match in CMLL with Los Ingobernables that I find to be a certified classic and one of the most chaotic trios in Arena Mexico history. Motivates me to look deeper into his Mexican work and see if it can grow his case further.

A total lock for my top 30 at this point, probably top 25 and potentially trending up after further investigation.
 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...