Not exactly a Hot Take. I can't imagine anyone in their right mind disagreeing with this.
As a wrestler, yes. As a draw? The other things that usually go with being a WON HOF member? I could maybe buy influence because of Dragon Gate, but it's a lose call.
He was one of the top 3 cruiserweights in WCW, for whatever that's worth.
If he influenced Dragon Gate, that's pretty big.
Also, there's a move named after him (that I think he also invented) - the Asai Moonsault.
Good enough for the WON HOF.
It evolved from Toryumon which he founded and he also trained a lot of the mainstays for DG.