93-96 Shawn feels like the 4th best guy in the company (behind Bret, Owen, Waltman). I don't see how being the 4th best guy in a promotion that was really low in quality as a great resume.
Rockers are like the 8th best teams in the 80s, so that won't make him a definite.
Hate the comeback, so that just leaves 97-98. Is six months at a great level with some other solid years enough? No, especially since his comeback was such shit and the heel run in 91-93 was not really good.