Here's a thing.
If AJ was presented strong throughout, if he was debuted even more strongly, if he was protected in his first couple of matches (a showcase to debut, for instance, his offense not kicked out of so much so early), if he won at Wrestlemania, then this would matter even more right now.
That's what they do in NXT. That's what they do in lucha Underground. If AJ was going to be challenging upcoming in either of those places, they wouldn't have had his offense kicked out of so much and wouldn't have had him lose.
Is it good that he's the challenger and not Jericho or whatever? Sure. Is it a push? Sure. But there's a way to build a guy most effectively, and this wasn't it. No "Oh we got fooled!" moments change that.
He was just another guy last night. Tonight, he was the just another guy that they're giving a title shot. He was the midcarder, out of four midcarders, that was getting that nod.
Almost every wrestling territory in the 80s would have built him different. Vince, in the 80s or 90s, would have built him differently.
None of this changes that. That's history.
It was a good moment. It should have been better. I'm sick of settling because the either can't or don't want to actually get anyone over. It's not rocket science. It's wrestling.