Jump to content
Pro Wrestling Only

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 93
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Thanks. I'll rate matches, but not with stars. I'll be using a 1-10 scale, breaking down in 0.1. In reviewing 140 matches a month, I think I need something a bit more precise to make comparisons. Plus, I think Dave has recently made star ratings laughably irrelevant. I'll elaborate on this more later, but I really want those ratings to not just reflect the in-ring bell to bell, but to rate the match as an overall presentation, the lion's share which is of course the in-ring bell to bell. The flaw of star ratings has always been the awesome five-minute matches that no one's going to go all the way on no matter how good they are. Or the matches that do everything they need to do, but aren't technically great. Or the matches that are aided by hot promo work or a post-match angle. The 1-10 rating is not just "this is how great this match is", even if it's often that. It's more my opinion of how worth your time the whole shebang is.

Posted

Thanks. I'll rate matches, but not with stars. I'll be using a 1-10 scale, breaking down in 0.1. In reviewing 140 matches a month, I think I need something a bit more precise to make comparisons. Plus, I think Dave has recently made star ratings laughably irrelevant. I'll elaborate on this more later, but I really want those ratings to not just reflect the in-ring bell to bell, but to rate the match as an overall presentation, the lion's share which is of course the in-ring bell to bell. The flaw of star ratings has always been the awesome five-minute matches that no one's going to go all the way on no matter how good they are. Or the matches that do everything they need to do, but aren't technically great. Or the matches that are aided by hot promo work or a post-match angle. The 1-10 rating is not just "this is how great this match is", even if it's often that. It's more my opinion of how worth your time the whole shebang is.

 

Sounds like a win. I love a detailed, qualitative match review as the best give me something to think about on the match at hand as well as impact what I look for thereafter, but absent some type of rating -- stars, letters, numbers, whatever works for the author -- it can be difficult to differentiate and distinguish. Needless to say this sounds like a great way to address everything.

Posted

Hey, everyone. If anyone would like to help, I need more Facebook likes, as it makes it much easier to promote the page. If you haven't liked the page, it would be very appreciated if you would. Also, please invite any wrestling fan friends that you have on Facebook to like the page as well. Thanks to all!

Posted

Would there be a way to manage old links and Google results?

The GWE megathread links and any that you click on via Google read 404 not found. :(

Posted

Really digging the new layout and all the content so far. The layout is great and really gives it a different feel from all those shady news sites. Please don't burn yourself out, though.

Posted

Congratulations on the relaunch!

One question that jumped to mind - have you considered opening a PWO Patreon?  There are a number of independent sites or creators that use Patreon to allow their communities to support their work.

Posted

Thank you! And yes, I have. I'm still determining what makes the most sense to add at the various tiers. I have some ideas I'm still toying with.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

Just wanted to add that I purchased a Virtual Pro Wrestling 2 shirt from the link Loss posted on Twitter to support the site.  In related news, my wallet is also cursing Loss for the upcoming abuse it's about to get from me finding this site. 

Posted
2 hours ago, sek69 said:

Just wanted to add that I purchased a Virtual Pro Wrestling 2 shirt from the link Loss posted on Twitter to support the site.  In related news, my wallet is also cursing Loss for the upcoming abuse it's about to get from me finding this site. 

Missed that tweet and can't seem to find it, do you have the link?

  • Loss unpinned this topic

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...