One thing I always thought about the Iconic Duo, even in their NXT days, is that Billie Kay dragged the act down a bit, thus hindering Peyton. If Kay - who weirdly got worse compared to her indie days - were to be on the same level as Royce, no doubt the act would be a home run, but it doesn't feel like they can reach absurd highs.
The bigger issue, however, is that I don't feel like the material they are getting indicates they are going to be treated any better than the Riott Squad or Absolution. They had a very strong debut, but the following weeks it kind of dwindled away.
I hope I am wrong.