It's actually a criticism I have of Steven's list that he's seemingly blind to the flaws of a guy like Larry Z who he rewards for the times he's on, but then totally harsh on a guy like Shawn for the times he's off.
I've said this a few times, so I will say it again. It's just not that Shawn sucked for his whole return, it's also the fact he wasn't good as a singles from 92-96. He had the 96-97 run which was good to great and he had the run as a good tag worker. Anybody else with that resume would not make my list.