What Current WWE Active Roster Members Will Make Your Ballot?

[Dylan Waco]

I realize we have had a bunch of threads like this tonight, but I'm genuinely curious about this. For me I know I'll have Cena and Styles (though of course that has nothing to do with his WWE run so far), and I'm virtually certain Cesaro will sneak his way onto the bottom portion. After that I'm either blanking, or there is no one else I can say for sure will make the cut.

[NotJayTabb]

Looking through my current list, I've got more than I would have guessed: Dustin, Sheamus, Henry, Orton, Cena, Styles, with Sami Zayn on my "maybe" list.

[Jimmy Redman]

Cena, AJ, Joe, Henry, Show, Sami, Itami, Orton, Jericho, Sheamus, Undertaker, Hunter, Brock, Cesaro, Dustin. I think that's everybody.

[Dylan Waco]

Completely forgot about Dustin Rhodes. He'll make my list for sure. Joe and Sheamus have a shot, though I'm not certain on either.

[Jimmy Redman]

No Brock?

[soup23]

Cena, Dustin, AJ, Brock look probable for me.

 

Good shot for Sami Zayn and perhaps Cesaro.

[Matt D]

Cena, Dustin, Henry, Cesaro, probably Sheamus

[El McKell]

It's very possible that not all of these guys will make my list but right now they're all more likely to be on it than not.

Cena, Samoa Joe, Orton, Triple H, Undertaker, Brock, Generico, AJ Styles, KENTA, Jericho, Rollins, Cesaro, Austin Aries, Shinsuke Nakamura.

Does Sting count?

[WingedEagle]

Cena, Brock, Styles and Dustin are the only locks.

[Grimmas]

John Cena, Bock Lesnar, Dustin Rhodes, and AJ Styles are on for sure.

 

Samoa Joe might sneak on.

[GOTNW]

KENTA, Cena, AJ, Nakamura. Brock is probably falling off at this point. I've considered Zayn but I don't think he'll make it.

[The Man in Blak]

Dustin and Cena are locks, though I suspect I'll be lower on Cena than most. Cesaro and Undertaker are currently floating around the bottom 10-15, but not guaranteed. Joe and Nakamura might sneak on as well, depending on how my remaining homework for them plays out.

[Matt D]

Styles and Joe are guys I might make a last run at watching more of.

[Goodear]

I'm very American-centrc in my tastes so my list has lots of WWE/WCW representation... anyway.

 

Brock, Cena, Dustin, Cesaro, Owens, Zayn, Jericho, Samoa Joe, Bubba Ray Dudley, Mark Henry

[Yo-Yo's Roomie]

Goldust. Possibly Jericho.

[InYourCase]

Zayn, Cena, Aries, Joe, Styles, Cesaro, and Brock are locks. Owens is on the bubble.

[concrete1992]

Counting for my own purposes of people that I think are likely at this time:

1. Joe
2. Styles
3. Cena
4. Cesaro
5. Sheamus
6. Brock
7. Show
8. Goldust
9. Zayn

I think at least.

[Loss]

John Cena, Chris Jericho, AJ Styles, Samoa Joe and Goldust are the only ones that have a chance, and I'm not even 100% sure they will all make it.

[Childs]

Cena, Dustin, Styles, Joe, Brock, Cesaro, Nakamura.

[cm funk]

Taker, Brock, Cena, Jericho and AJ belong in the conversation IMO. Not saying any of them are the GOAT......but they at least belong in the conversation for various different reasons

 

I'd add Nakamura and Joe.....but I don't consider them "active roster" yet

 

I'd also add Big Show to the list.....but I realize that won't be popular on this board.....so I didn't say it

[Matt D]

Big Show has a very outside chance at 100.

[Jimmy Redman]

Why wouldn't you? I'm voting for Show.

[Cross Face Chicken Wing]

Cena, Dustin, Taker.....maybe Brock.

[Childs]

I'd also add Big Show to the list.....but I realize that won't be popular on this board.....so I didn't say it

 

I think plenty of people here like Show. I view his career positively overall and consider his performance in the Mayweather match to be one of the most impressive in company history. He just never had the sustained run of greatness that would push him into my top 100.

[Loss]

Serious question about Brock. How is him eating up opponents okay when guys like Hansen and Brody or Adonis and Murdoch get criticized for it? Is it a matter of him just eating people up being more entertaining to watch or is it something else? The only reason I'm not ranking Brock is that I think he's pretty one dimensional. He can kick ass in a fun way, but I don't see a strong grasp of psychology or the ability to sell or anything like that.

 

I don't see how Brock is demonstrably better than The Road Warriors, who I don't see get much praise as workers.