-
Posts
13071 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Blogs
Everything posted by Matt D
-
There's an art to that. It's awesome.
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
I am well outside the circle of trust now. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
The mid-south crowd was perfectly suited for him in a lot of ways. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
I still think Blassie was part of the key to moving into California for some people. (But just part of it) -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
Their finisher is the quadruple limb wrencher. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
Incidentally, according to Kris, Arn is Ole's son in law. (non-kayfabe). The world needs more proof than what was provided though. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
Southeastern is one of those promotions (like Memphis and on some level AWA) which just feels very much like it should feel. The rosters are spot on but not very interesting to me because they're so spot on (which isn't a bad thing by any means. I'm just wanting chaos) and it'll be in the booking. goc is, of course, Southwest, and we'll keep being confused about that as we move forward. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
I will not run from being put on the spot but i will deflect. Success is a tricky metric, as mentioned, but I know the ones I am most interested in. Sometimes it's just seeing how someone fits into a territory, like Adonis in GCW. I have full faith in Kris to hit the ground running with that. He has a roster that hits his region's sweet spot perfectly but adds a few new elements. WWC is like that too as Kris and Boricua obviously know their stuff. I know some of goc's plans for Southeastern and I'm looking forward to seeing them play out. That, like Central States, is a territory that was so handicapped in real life that any improvement is a success. Then you get a place like Portland which did okay but now has some new elements to take it a bit more over the top. ICW being weird and surreal and outlaw should be fun too. Everyone's put thought into this but it's kind of mad to see the amount around Maple Leaf and WWF. I wonder if you guys have been doing anything BUT this lately. On paper, though, I think best balance of hitting the right tone + adding interesting elements, is probably Florida, especially after the trade for Hennig. Ultimately, I don't think anyone had a bad draft. There are some territories which were not done the way I would have, mind you. In the end, it's all down to the booking. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
Joking aside (and there has been joking), I'm glad to see that so many people drafted so differently. Some people created a territory that looked a lot like the real territory. Others created one that would feel like the real territory but had different players. Others went completely different, etc. It should make things interesting moving forward. -
Yeah, I'm leaning back towards performance art. sorry.
-
Match Ratings - Doing Away With the Meltzer * Formula
Matt D replied to Fantastic's topic in Pro Wrestling
There's not a right answer here. Match A can be good in one aspect. Match B can be good in another. Match C can be great in one way but not another. Listmaking and comparisons are great, but if you can go into a match and point out the ways it hits, the ways it misses, your overall feeling of it, the crowd's feeling, if it accomplishes what it's set out to do (which sometimes has nothing to do with traditional metrics of quality), etc. To me that's the most interesting thing in a review. 1. Are you taking a 360 look at the match. 2. How do you feel about it taking all that in. Just admit your biases as best you can. -
They had done a really good job with the Itami episode too. It's the sort of feature stuff that you never see on Raw/Smackdown, WWE TV save for maybe those weekly sit down interviews (and even then it's still night and day).
-
It's a fictional narrative. When good, it's an entertaining, coherent fictional narrative. When bad, it's not so entertaining and not so coherent, but still a fictional narrative. I'm cool with my classification along those lines. It's okay if you disagree.
-
It's way more of an art than a sport though, which is my point 78% of the time.
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
In general, I think the communists were heavily undervalued in this draft. 1983 people. -
He just drafted Cortez the Cuban?
-
I think I'm going to start running with "Wrestling is fiction" instead of wrestling is art. That one's fair, if only because it distracts.
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
That was a brutal 3-5 picks in a row for guys who were left. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
The best resource is Kris Z. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
There'll just have to be more proxies. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
Best I can come up with is a Little Egypt joke. Forget it. -
Match Ratings - Doing Away With the Meltzer * Formula
Matt D replied to Fantastic's topic in Pro Wrestling
I admit that my lack of star ratings are a bit of a cop out, but I really don't watch matches to compare, most of the time. I'm in it for enjoyment, but mainly for understanding, not ranking. They're not mutually exclusive obviously, but I tend not to switch my mind into that other gear unless I have to. -
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Matt D replied to Cross Face Chicken Wing's topic in The Archives
See, I made the right call. Controversy was averted. -
And the challenge of it is half the fun.