PWO Critics Guild Hall of Fame

[JerryvonKramer]

Fuck Meltzer. I'm establishing this. Act one: appoint Dylan Waco as President and Chairman.

 

Agenda for first meeting:

 

1. Criteria

2. How many fiat picks for Class of 2013

3. Who are the fiat picks?

4. Ballot for 2014

 

Deadline: Christmas Day.

[evilclown]

I am only going to vote for Kurt Angle and Shawn Michaels because fuck jdw! He can't tell me what to do.

[goodhelmet]

Fuck you... The goodhelmet hall is already established.

[BrickHithouse]

I nominate Bulldog Bob Brown. It takes a special guy to wrestle 4-5 decades and not break the 2 star barrier.

[soup23]

Fuck Meltzer. I'm establishing this. Act one: appoint Dylan Waco as President and Chairman.

 

Agenda for first meeting:

 

1. Criteria

2. How many fiat picks for Class of 2013

3. Who are the fiat picks?

4. Ballot for 2014

 

Deadline: Christmas Day.

1. Let me think about it although I'm inclined to say that no one should get in based on workrate alone. This kills two birds with one stone (less subjective opinion weight and NO BENOIT). I also am conflicted on the non wrestler portion.

2. I would limit this to around 10-20 guys

3. The biggest no brainers in wrestling history (Londos, Rock, Santo, Hogan, Flair, Bruno) etc.

4. I would keep the 10-20 added per year.

[JerryvonKramer]

I'm only half-joking with this, could be interesting if people treat it with even a quarter of the seriousness as they do the WON HoF.

 

I think Meltzer has botched that HoF, for various reasons, but well let's see if hypothetically we could do any better.

[MikeCampbell]

I nominate Bulldog Bob Brown. It takes a special guy to wrestle 4-5 decades and not break the 2 star barrier.

Forget him. No HOF has any credibility without Canada's greatest athlete!

[cheapshot]

This actually could be a fun project that would most definitely generate debate.

 

Big Daddy as one of the class of 2013, right?

[BrickHithouse]

I'd put Dr. George Zahorian in the non-wrestler wing, if there is one.

[Matt D]

I'm actually pretty cool with the Goodhelmet hall. I might want Satanico instead of Dandy but that's just because I haven't hit the back end of the 80s set yet.

[El-P]

I vote for Raven and Nobuhiko Takada.

[evilclown]

Juventud Guerrera would be on my first ballot and that's a shoot.

[Matt D]

On second thought, I just want Bockwinkel and Rose and no one else. It'll be more like a cabinet of fame.

[bradhindsight]

Act one: appoint Dylan Waco as President and Chairman.

I'll second this.

 

 

As an aside - where is the goodhelmut hall? Is there a physical location on the internet for this? Can we build it?

[goodhelmet]

5570925[/url]']

I'm actually pretty cool with the Goodhelmet hall. I might want Satanico instead of Dandy but that's just because I haven't hit the back end of the 80s set yet.

Satanico is in the third wave.

[goodhelmet]

5570933[/url]']

5570911[/url]' date='Nov 6 2013, 12:30 PM']Act one: appoint Dylan Waco as President and Chairman.

I'll second this.

 

 

As an aside - where is the goodhelmut hall? Is there a physical location on the internet for this? Can we build it?

 

It is only in my mind. You can't build that which cannot be torn down.

[Loss]

Wrestling needs another Hall of Fame like I need a hole in my head.

[cheapshot]

Wrestling needs another Hall of Fame like I need a hole in my head.

We have numerous HoF's, even a Hall Of Pain (thanks Mizark!), but doing a Hall of Shame could be fun. (Worst angles, workers, gimmicks, promotions) Kinda like Wrestlecrap, but better.

[Dylan Waco]

I don't have an interest in this. Well let me amend that. I would have an interest in something like this if it were directly related to projects that have sprung up on this board, but a broad big picture HoF? Nah.

[Bigelow34]

I don't have an interest in this. Well let me amend that. I would have an interest in something like this if it were directly related to projects that have sprung up on this board, but a broad big picture HoF? Nah.

Can we have one focused on the specific wrestling fetishes housed within PWO?

[Matt D]

I don't have an interest in this. Well let me amend that. I would have an interest in something like this if it were directly related to projects that have sprung up on this board, but a broad big picture HoF? Nah.

Can we have one focused on the specific wrestling fetishes housed within PWO?

 

 

Apparently we all REALLY like Nicho el Millonari or something. I always liked Psicosis mask.

[rainmakerrtv]

Fuck you... The goodhelmet hall is already established.

I've long said that the Rob Vincent (my name) Pro Wrestling Hall Of Fame has at its entrance statues on either side of Dick Murdoch and Barry Windham, looking like before and after photos.

[Zenjo]

Wrestling needs another Hall of Fame like I need a hole in my head.

You need lots of holes in your head, but +1 to the sentiment.

[JerryvonKramer]

[Log]

If my wife's cool with it, we could have the physical hall in my garage. Might have to share space with our Christmas decorations, though.